The legendary power and volume of the Who was always best sampled live. The studio tended to deaden their electricity: they recorded some fabulous singles, but no truly perfect albums. Even Tommy suffered from pretentious production. Live at Leeds, then, is not just possibly the greatest live album of all time, but also almost certainly the Who's finest moment.The album caught the band soon after touring Tommy in its entirety, itching to cut loose. A show at Britain's Leeds University on Valentine's Day 1970 was the location; the band surged at full strength for more than two hours, playing Tommy, their classic singles, and a clutch of rock 'n' roll gems along the way. Unrestrained onstage, the power trio of musicians behind Roger Daltrey swelled to fearsome strength—bassist John Entwhistle carrying the melodies, drummer Keith Moon rolling and filling with powerhouse abandon, and Pete Townshend proving himself a pioneer of feedback and dynamics, his terse solos full of ideas and emotion, a truly understated guitarist.The resulting album arrived later that year, packaged like a faux bootleg in a shabby cardboard gatefold. Though later expanded on CD (2000's completed two-CD deluxe edition is the one to buy), the original six-track vinyl is perfect in itself, especially the devil-driven cover of Mose Allison's "Young Man Blues," and the sprawling "My Generation," which soon becomes a kaleidoscope of windmill riffage. Live at Leeds is as pure as heavy rock gets.
Joe:
"No perfect albums" is an interesting take, only because that statement is true for most, if not all, musical artists that have ever existed in the history of music. Can you name a perfect album, without being hyperbolic? Even my favorite albums of all time have minor flaws. They are flaws that I can easily overlook because of how brilliant the art is overall, and so, calling something "imperfect" is unfair and sort of pointless. But I get the point here. The author is building a case for Live at Leeds. They need to imply that "Cousin Kevin" on Tommy exists and therefore Tommy is worse than Live at Leeds. I get it.
But I've never agreed with it. I've always been pretty reticent to get into live albums. I think that it's certainly possible that there are days in which a live album hits better than a studio album (especially if said live album acts as a greatest hits compilation). But I don't respect the artistry as much. I see the studio album as the statement, and the live album as an extension of that statement, merely a limb that juts out and could easily be sawed off if need be. This is why it's taken me over 20 years to finally listen to the exalted live album from the Who that I've been cognizant of and pestered with by the gatekeepers this entire time. It's a good album. It's a great album. It has no business being compared to the Who's studio albums.
This is my argument to view Live at Leeds in the proper context. Fuck out of here with "no perfect albums." You simply cannot compare. And so, if you remove it from that context, and just listen to it in a vacuum, then it's easier for me to evaluate. In that vacuum, I say that Live at Leeds is great fun. Agreed on all other counts—the Who sound to me like a wild live act, at least back in the '70s (not so much today probably, R.I.P. Keith Moon and John Entwhistle). The appropriate flowers have been given, I'm sure, for "My Generation," which turns into a Tommy medley, but my money is on "Magic Bus" as the one that goes hardest. Could be a matter of comparing/contrasting to the studio version, how "My Generation" was already pretty wild and "Magic Bus" was relatively scaled back and subdued, and when both go off the rails in concert, "Magic Bus" appears to be more a revelation.
As is the PoYB standard, I listened to the original version, and not the bonus deluxe version that doubles or triples the album's length. Six songs, all killer and no filler. I wouldn't mind hearing Tommy performed live in its entirety, but I also think that that would be too much of a good thing. I already have Tommy. I can just listen to that album. I don't need to hear it in a "different" way. The original studio album is great. Not perfect, sure, but c'mon. No need to throw that word around. Ain't no fucking live album that's perfect either. Certainly not Live at Leeds. Good, though.
Listen:

No comments:
Post a Comment