Welcome to Monday Morning Mixtape, a PoYB Contributor-curated playlist of songs, made just for you at the start of each week.
"Robbie Robertson's Microphone Is Off"
Songs sung by a member of the band who isn't normally the lead vocalist
chosen by Joe
"Up the Devil's Pay" by Old 97's
from Satellite Rides, 2001
Joe was educating me on the fishhook and horseshoe theories of political philosophy recently. It boils down, more or less, that the further right you get, you begin to curve back around. Whether the far right is more like a moderate republican or a leftist is the shape you adopt.
In the past, Nate described me as a real Murray, in reference to Old 97's' goofy bass player and occasional singer. I didn't take too kindly to that comparison. We all want to be the hunky Rhett Miller, not the bespectacled weirdo singing backup. But over time, Murray Hammond has taken up a warm place in my heart. This backhanded compliment has curved around, and I'm proud to be a Murray. As always, fuck you, Nate. —Sam
"Demons" by Guster
from Goldfly, 1997
Adam Gardner used to sing most of Guster's songs, but now he's been replaced exclusively by Ryan Miller, basically ever since Keep It Together came out in 2003. Goldfly was a great record, though, and this is one of the classic songs. Levine understatedly kills it. Guster has gotten a lot of positive press in the last week for its Kennedy Center shows. Maybe the haters will finally realize them for more than just bongo music. —Zach
"Foolmuse" by Peter Cat Recording Co.
"Foolmuse" by Peter Cat Recording Co.
from BETA, 2024
"Could I be a muse? / Or something of use? / Oh, won't you save me? / Won't you keep me like no one you knew?" Love Peter Cat. I loved seeing them at TLA this past fall. Although Suryakant has such an undeniable stage presence, and honestly sex appeal (especially when he smoked a cigarette while singing), one of the highlights of the show for me was when they did "Foolmuse," and Kartik Pillai, usually on guitar, sang this song which he also wrote. —Gloria
"Have a Cigar" by Pink Floyd
"Have a Cigar" by Pink Floyd
from Wish You Were Here, 1975
This song has been stuck in my head since I read the theme. I didn't know who sang it, but I knew it wasn't David Gilmour or even Roger Waters. When I looked it up, it was Roy Harper—not a member of Pink Floyd but a prolific artist in his own right. It's fitting to have this song by someone outside of the band, given it's sung from the perspective of a record company exec who is urging the band to "ride the gravy train" with the momentum built off the success of their previous album, The Dark Side of the Moon. The witty, tongue-in-cheek lyrics are delivered so well from this outside voice: "Well, I've always had a deep respect, and I mean that most sincerely / The band is just fantastic, that is really what I think / Oh by the way, which one's Pink?" —Gloria
"I'm in Love with My Car" by Queen
from A Night at the Opera, 1975
For some reason, Joe hates "Bohemian Rhapsody." He apparently thinks it's one of the worst songs he's ever heard, but I challenge that it's not even Queen's worst song! It's not even Queen's worst song from the same album! "I'm in Love with My Car" is a song that only sounds like a Queen song if you remove the lyrics and vocals. Written and sung by drummer Roger Taylor, guitarist Brain May originally thought Taylor was joking when he wrote it. But Taylor says the song is only "kind of tongue in cheek," which makes me wonder if Taylor really loves his car more than any of the women in his life... Either way, I'm curious if others feel that this is a dumb song, which makes me feel less bad about suggesting a song I don't really get behind because it's all in the name of a dialogue about music. Or something. —Batts
"Seymour Stein" by Belle & Sebastian
"Seymour Stein" by Belle & Sebastian
from The Boy with the Arab Strap, 1998
For years, I thought this band consisted of two people, one named Belle, one named Sebastian. Oh, to find out I was wrong! They have a magical sound that no other band has. Also, I'm writing this from a street coffee shop where the people watching is top-notch. Is there more to life than this? —Zach
"Song for the Deaf" by Queens of the Stone Age
"Song for the Deaf" by Queens of the Stone Age
from Songs for the Deaf, 2002
This is one of those bands and albums I always liked, but never got super into. They were always just floating around the background during the college days. Radio, house parties, Rock Band, whatever. But on the few occasions I did listen through the whole album cramming for a test, I noticed they changed it up with vocals; it wasn't always Homme singing. Is this band still making music? A quick google shows that Lanegan died a few years ago, and Homme needs emergency surgery. Welp. —Sunny
"Your Graduation" by Modern Baseball
from You're Gonna Miss It All, 2014
How did you celebrate your high school graduation? The movies make it seem like someone's parents go out of town on the day of your graduation and that person invites the whole school over to their house for one final epic party before everyone goes their separate ways forever. I wasn't invited to that one. Me and my cousin-not-related Harry had a chill family-and-friends party at a beef and beer hall, though. Our parents were cool with us drinking pitchers of beer. Nothing too crazy happened. My boss from the retirement home, the late Barbara M., was there, so me and some of her other subordinates shared some beers with her for the first time (she was a good friend of my mom's, hence how I got the job in the first place). Let's see, what else? I got drunk and asked my friend Maryrose if she wanted to be friends-with-benefits. She said no. She had a kid with someone else pretty soon afterward. Maybe I celebrated my high school graduation by not becoming a father. And uhhh... where was I going with this? —Joe
"911 Is a Joke" by Public Enemy
"911 Is a Joke" by Public Enemy
from Fear of a Black Planet, 1990
I called 911 because I was working a shift in the box next to the other box where they keep the kids who are adjudicated dependent, and so I was in charge or reporting the cops when one of those kids ran away. And let's not be dramatic—"run away" means that they were walking to Wendy's and didn't feel like signing themselves out. But still I was required to call the police, so now some asshole is sitting in the box with me, rolling his eyes because he's like every other cop in that he hates people who aren't cops and so hates the kid he's taking the report about on principle alone. But he's taking the report. And I can sense he's being an asshole about it, and so I probably gave him a short answer to one of his careless questions, and he says something like, "jeez, and I thought I was cynical." Nah, brah, don't mistake it. I'm not cynical about Philadelphia and the people in it. I'm just cynical about you. —Joe
"Act Naturally" by the Beatles
from Help!, 1965
You ever check out Ringo Starr's acting career? Dude was passable in A Hard Day's Night, and the movie industry and the man himself thought that's what he should be doing. This song (a cover) kind of winks at that idea, but I wonder if Ringo was in on the joke. John Lennon seems like the kind of mean-spirited fuck to do one for Ringo but laughing behind his back the whole time. Well, jokes on you, Johnny. Ringo's still alive, and even had a weird CBS special for L.A. fire victims recently. Though he didn't play this song. —Sam
"Boys" by the Beatles
"Boys" by the Beatles
from Please Please Me, 1963
Arguably the best song that Ringo sings? That's just one blogger's opinion, and probably an unpopular one, but I'm going to put "Boys" over "With a Little Help from My Friends" and "Octopus’s Garden." I've been digging those early-'60s grooves lately. Ringo was sick a lot as a child, having peritonitis, tuberculosis, and appendicitis, among other things. He was hospitalized for the majority of his youth, and was encouraged by medical staff to stay active to stimulate motor function. He started drumming on the cabinets near his bed, and eventually joined the hospital band on his ward. It was a crazy way to learn how to drum, and perhaps a reason for his unique style. —Gloria
"Happy" by the Rolling Stones
"Happy" by the Rolling Stones
from Exile on Main St., 1972
I recently talked with some friends about how we used to pick up people at bars when we were younger. One of the things I forgot to mention was that I used to ask someone I was chatting with, "Do you like the Beatles or the Rolling Stones better?" if I was trying to figure out where the evening was heading. If they said the Beatles, I assumed they were a nice person with good taste in music; we'd exchange numbers and plan to hang out in the upcoming days. If they said the Rolling Stones, I knew I could go home with them that night, haha. And I figured they probably weren't worth my effort if they didn't have an answer. Wholesome vs. Rebellious vs. Boring. Why I started asking this question is long lost from my memory, but I remember that the responses to this question were accurate 9/10 times. Let me know your answer in the comments, and if you think my interpretation is accurate! —Gloria
"In the Cold, Cold Night" by the White Stripes
from Elephant, 2003
Thinking about the little punk-ass bitch Freddy from that Jack Black rock film, ya know the one, with the school, and the kids, and this little fuck is walking down the halls of his school and he's being all misogynistic like yo girls can't drum and Katie is like well Meg White can and this little shitstain winces like SHE CAN'T DRUM and I think it woulda been a better movie if Katie had thrown a bow toward Freddy's face and given him a fat lip 'cause Meg White sure as shit can drum she's one of the best she's one of the fucking best and I'll put that little fucking turd Freedy in the fucking ground if he keeps talking shit Meg White is an essential piece of one of the best rock outfits of all time and Jack White wouldn't have been shit without her and she proved every second of every goddamn song that drummers are the bedrock of any good band they are they to support to help they very rarely are the star but maybe even occasionally they are like if they sing lead once or whatever, when that happens it's brave, and I swear to fucking god if Freddy keeps talking shit I'll kill that motherfucker, oh shit what's that now, he's already dead? Oh no, oh no. I'm sorry. Sincerely just learned that sobering fact in the middle of writing this blurb. Oh jeez. —Joe
"Little Miss Strange" by the Jimi Hendrix Experience
from Electric Ladyland, 1968
Took me about seven years, 500 full listens, and five semesters with a posted of the full band (not just Jimi) hanging on my dorm room walls before I realized that my favorite Hendrix album was called Electric Ladyland and not Electric Landlady. This, despite the lyrics on the album that tell me as much. I am not a smart man. Alright Joe that's micro-anecdote #1, now tells us micro-anecdote #2. Okay then I will. The first time I ever listened to Electric Landlady, I was kinda tired, and I started to fall asleep a little bit during "1983... (A Merman I Should Turn to Be)." I count this as the closest I've ever come to a psychedelic experience (having never used drugs). I saw colors, shapes, whole scenes, brah. Kinda made me proud that Hendrix described these songs as "paintings" and not "songs" because I saw the paintings, maaaan. Bassist Noel Redding I assume had smaller ambitions, and does a very good job with the garage rocker that he provides vocals for. —Joe
"To Kingdom Come" by the Band
from Music from Big Pink, 1968
There are certain things that you cannot deny. Robbie Robertson is undoubtedly the fourth-best singer in the Band, and that ranking is not "worst singer in the Band" only because Garth Hudson never attempted to grab the mic. You can't deny it's shaky enough that it was the right call to cut the mic during The Last Waltz. You also can't deny that "To Kingdom Come" is actually a really fun song, and the creaky, strained vocals do nothing to damage it. Other things are more deniable. Why did Robbie Robertson get so many writing credits on songs from the Band if their efforts are so undeniable of the group, together? If you read Levon Helm's autobiography, you get to the final page thinking that Robertson is a fucking snake in the grass. That's what happened to me. The whiplash I then received from reading the Wikipedia page and seeing Robertson's counterargument (Helm has numerous solo albums and a total of one measly writing credit on all of them combined) was informative of how persuasive someone can be when you read their words in increments of 100,000. Robertson is dead now. So is Helm. So is everyone from the Band. We might never know the full truth. We have the partial truth, though. It's on the recording. Good song, "To Kingdom Come." Good enough. Can't deny it. —Joe
NEXT WEEK: "Reunion Tour" — Singles or songs from albums that were released after a gap/hiatus of ten years or more for the artist (chosen by Batts)

10 comments:
SONG ORDER: Artists grouped together, first names that start with vowels, then names that start with consonants, and then names that start with "the." Songs alphabetical within those groups.
Also, I'm getting a late start on the mixtape today, SEPTA had us sitting on the tracks for an extra 30 minutes or so.
The Queen song is pretty hilarious, and I think I might download this song for my iPod, so maybe someday in the future, a person who does not have the same taste in music as me is scrolling through the artists on my iPod and says something like, "Oh cool, you have Queen on here?" and then they click and it's literally just "I'm in Love with My Car."
I appreciate that me and Sunny both did the same bit this week in which we find out about someone's death mid-blurb.
I wanted to do this theme because I realized recently that I'm really bad at point out instances of this, even when it's obvious. There are songs on this mixtape today that I am familiar with and never knew that it wasn't the lead vocalist singing. The Peter Cat song for sure, and the QotSA track too. I'm only halfway through the mixtape so there are probably a couple more.
I'm really glad Keith Richards made the cut today. His insistence on singing over the course of the history of the Rolling Stones, despite being a pretty terrible singer, is a just punishment for this band who kept the awful drummer Charlie Watts on the payroll for decades.
And no, there are no RS songs in which Charlie Watts sings lead, because he was a miserable asshole. At least Keith Richards is having fun with it.
Best song is "Have a Cigar," and Gloria was right to point out the "By the way, which one's Pink?" line, probably the funniest lyric in all of classic rock.
Album to be downloaded by default comes down to Satellite Rides and Goldfly. If I don't go with the latter, then I don't want anyone to think I don't appreciate the good resistance at the Kennedy Center, and I can absolutely confirm from other Guster experience that they aren't just a bongo band.
But I'll go with Old 97's. (Though I'll quibble with the description of the fishhook theory as I see it—it's not that the far right looks moderate, it's that, in practice, spineless moderates sound exactly like far-right conservatives.)
@ Zach. Oh, should I even admit this? Today is the day I learned that there is no one named Belle or Sebastian in Belle & Sebastian. I knew there were other members, but I thought they started it, haha
@Joe, dying at Electric Landlady, hahah
Haha, it's just such a dumb song. And having a Queen song where Freddy Mercury ISN'T the lead vocalist as the one song in your library is essentially the same as a "Rick Roll."
Admit it proudly! I think I only learned this fact this year.
Post a Comment