Monday, February 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 20: Joe

Prompt: "A song with the most disgusting curse word you can imagine"

Selected by Joe


"The Ballad of the Kingsmen"
Todd Snider
East Nashville Skyline, 2004

When you see a prompt and it could mean at least five different things, then you have no choice but to find a song that meets all five requirements at once. This is Puke on Your Birthday's "The Ballad of 'The Ballad of the Kingsmen.'"

You could go historical. The song talks about the FBI investigation regarding the words in "Louie Louie," and whether it had any "disgusting curse words" that were affecting "the children's" "behavior." This is one of my favorite tidbits in the rock 'n' roll canon. Because not only did the FBI not find any evidence of lyrics so obscene that they could be considered illegal (after a 31-month investigation), but also, if you listen closely, you can actually hear drummer Lynn Easton yell "FUCK!" in the background because he screwed up a drum fill. One of the all-time great cases of actually doing the thing that the adults are accusing you of doing but getting away with it anyway. The curse word in this section: "Fuck"

You could go with retrospective irony. The second section in this song makes great points but uses an example that has aged very poorly. Here is the story of Marilyn Manson and the Columbine shooting, in miniature. Manson songs are no more at fault for children acting out than "Louie Louie" was, and yet the powers that be are always looking for a scapegoat when something bad happens, instead of acknowledging that these same powers have designed a rigged system in which of course people are going to act out in violent ways eventually, due to that immense pressure. But here in 2024, we know that this fucking creep is a violent abuser, and so maybe lines like "Now he gets all the girls" do some work to damage the integrity of the song. Correct, he's "not some monster from out of this world." He's very much a monster from this world, our world. No one's fault here but Brian Hugh Warner's. Todd Snider is still making a valid point overall, even if the example he used is no longer valid. The curse word in this section: "Marilyn Manson"

You could go humorous. Like, consider the fact that the final line of this song is an interpolation of Marvin Gaye's "Let's Get It On." It's a great humbling moment, how Todd Snider clearly feels at least a little uncomfortable acting as an outspoken political voice, and so he feels a pull to undercut the message by quoting the least political-motivated sex song of all time. Or maybe it's meta-commentary on the fact that Gaye also has one of the most famous and critically-acclaimed politically-motivated songs of all time in "What's Going On," and this is a tacit admission that a great musician should be able to do both. Regardless, we all know how lawsuit-happy those Gaye descendants are, and I'm honestly surprised that Todd Snider, despite being pretty far under the radar, hasn't been sued yet by the Gaye estate. The curse word in this section: "[any copyrighted word uttered by Marvin Gaye]"

You could go political, too, of course. Point out the fact that many people would consider the third section of this song "un-American," how it questions why our "free" country is so war-obsessed and gun-obsessed, and how it underlines the general point here, that it ain't the fucking music that's causing violence, but instead the insistence by our American society that we exist by "being strong," that resilience is a virtue even though it shouldn't have to be, that staying strong means being violent, that the infinite number of wars that America involves itself speak to this point. And then how we're taught in school that violence is necessary and also that the meek will inherit the earth and so the contradiction can fuck a kid up if you let it. The curse word in this section: "weapons," maybe

Or you could just be literal about it. Snider predicts that the next great act of violence might be blamed on Eminem and his (previous) penchant for saying the f-word (not fuck, the other one) in his music. I think back to a conversation that Stephan and I had (via email) about the Descendents album he picked for Record Club, and how the song "I'm Not a Loser" used homophobic language, and how, yes, it was mostly just a sign of the times, but also worth considering that the use of that particular language was supposed to be quoting the bullies that are beating the narrator up at school. I'm not trying to excuse the language, and I don't know if that necessarily blunts the negative impact it might have on the listener. Todd Snider is quoting Eminem here when he says the f-word, and he's not intending on using it in a homophobic way, but a question that one might consider is: does the use of the word, even ensconced in quotes, harm others? The curse word in this section: "f*g"

I've gone back and forth over the years regarding the responsibility of language to carry the weight of morality. I try to find a middle ground. I obviously think that language is important (seeing as how I spend a lot of time hanging around a blog that is mostly comprised of language, arranged in a particular way). I also think that people can sometimes tend to give it too much importance. Let's say it's an important thing but not the most important thing. I think intentions matter, but that intentions can be misguided.

I don't believe for one second that Todd Snider is intending to be homophobic by using the word, no more than I believe that the drummer of the Kingsmen was intending to corrupt the youth by yelling "fuck" in the background, or that Snider is condoning sex abuse by using Marilyn Manson to make a point, or that he's intentionally trying to piss off Marvin Gaye's nephew by quoting a famous song, or that he's unpatriotic by talking about how America is war-obsessed. But language has a way of complicating things, that's for sure. This is a complicated song, not because its thesis is complicated, but because the language used, on purpose or accidentally, complicates it significantly. 

I support Snider's use of these words in these lyrics for this song, because he has a point and it's an essential one and he uses this particular language to make that point. But I also don't think there's any room to be surprised when your words turn into a Rorschach test, and people hear certain words and interpret them exactly how they see fit. So language is important, and language is flexible, and language is delicate...? Something like that. I ain't so good with language myself. It's times like these when I think about the famous quote from the Kingsmen: "Ahmayaaah makaaaah aahh ooohoooh aaaaah."

No comments: