Thursday, February 8, 2024

The A.S.S. Creative Writing Lab: Prompt #6

This is a weekly space for creative writing. Please check out the landing page if you're interested in what we've written already, or if you yourself are interested in writing creatively. Feel free to comment below (according to the request feedback level) with any comments or suggestions!


Prompt:


Author: Melissa

Requested feedback: Light criticism

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Labels"

They had been on this planet for less than a day, and Captain Grandiose was already self-destructing. It didn't matter the years of training, the sacrifices, the mental fortitude, or his leadership role. In one day, this shit-for-brains was cracking. After our landing, it started; the claustrophobia leeched up his legs, through his chest, and finally clawed toward his brain. I watched as his sensibility dimmed, his eyes glassy, the tachycardia bringing his heart to new ventures in pace. I stared in awe at the man I was once in awe of as he pissed out the side window of our vessel. He was going to kill us. He was built for this program, and he was going to kill us.

They had warned us this could happen.

Manual 10, Section 229: Mental illness of any sort could be heightened in Space. Please be careful to prepare ahead of time with agents, therapists, and mentor Space Explorers.

Now, I marvel at the man we have sequestered. He rocks gently in the corner of his cabin and hums some unknown tune. I can't help but wonder again at the perfection of his countenance before it was shattered by Space itself.

5 comments:

Nate said...

Hi Melissa, first time long time. I think I understand the intention of the repeat-usage of "awe" in the final paragraph, but rather than express the drama and severity of the word's dual meaning, it distracted from the overall narrative.

Joe K said...

Now see, I was more distracted that narrator of this story appears to be our good pal Kev C*****.

Nah, just kiddng. I really appreciate the fact that other people (or at least Nate) are jumping in on the feedback.

Melissa, I'll have my full response by tomorrow. Thanks!

Joe K said...

Okay, here I am. Sorry for the delay. First, and most obvious: great job. Love it. I love how you took the notes from last time—the mention about how your last thing was based on a true story, which, again, wasn't even actually a criticism!—and did something here that is completely different. This is assuming you've never personally been trapped in space. So, main point is that I love the risk, and I think it paid off. It inspires me to do something like this next time out, really dive into the fictional or at least the metaphorical.

As far as "light criticism" is concerned, I'd prefer to frame it as "hey, let's talk about this one part of your writing." Because this one part isn't bad by any means, I quite liked it, but I'm curious to get your motivation behind it. The insert from the space manual. I would love to hear more about the choice to include this, and how you saw it as important. Felt to me like a bit of a stylistic outlier, and I wonder if that maybe is on purpose, that the outlier is SUPPOSED to make the reader feel disoriented, in the same way that maybe Captain Grandiose feels (and maybe the narrator feels too).

MongiCope said...

Hey! I think the space manual came from thinking about the "Captain Kev Connor" being a "manuals" guy. I also was thinking about a system vs. the reality. A system provides books and manuals and rules, but what would the reality be? So, yes, a stylistic outlier, but also another element of this character's mental processing as robotic.

MongiCope said...

Nate, I don't think I thought too long about it, but you're probably right. It is clunky. Whoops.