Saturday, February 10, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 19: Sunny

Prompt: "The most recent song you actually hate"

Selected by Sunny


"Fast Car"
Luke Combs
Gettin' Old, 2023

This was my knee jerk reaction for Day 14's prompt. Of all the "new music" that gets radio play, this track produced a visceral reaction. Credit where it's due, this is not the worst song on the air (I mean, that Tate McRae song) or even the worst on the Billboard. However, there was a certain shock from hearing this song, covered by Luke Combs of all people, over and over again on the radio late last year. Made the song stick in memory rather than in and out the ears like the typical pop slurry. It was one of those big hits that broke out of the genre radio station (country) and onto general Top 40. I remember mostly thinking "why?" and that this song fails the #1 media cover/remake/homage rule: don't remind the reader they'd rather be enjoying the better version. Still, Combs didn't change the pronouns in the song to suit his voice, which I liked.

Of course, Chapman and the original "Fast Car" need hardly any commentary. PoYB has already got it covered. What's interesting, and what I'll consider an "update" since thinking of using this song on this prompt back in December, is that the Grammys happened. Not that they happened, that's the least interesting thing in the world. But rather that, somehow, this year's Grammy Awards pulled Chapman onto a national stage on her terms, and that Combs was extremely supportive of her shaping the vision, and that he didn't change the pronouns in his cover so that all credit would, unequivocally, go to Chapman (in his thinking, anyway). Certainly well intentioned on Combs' part. And that, finally, all this buzz (joke though the Grammys are) would drive Chapman's song's streams and sales so that indeed, yes, we are listening to the better version. So thanks Luke, I guess.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

I was tossing around the idea of using the 33-minute live version of this song at some point for a prompt. Maybe not such a good idea.