Saturday, February 10, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 19: Nate

Prompt: "The most recent song you actually hate"

Selected by Nate


"Try That in a Small Town"
Jason Aldean
Highway Desperado, 2023

I am not saying that "Try That in a Small Town" is definitely, beyond a shadow of a doubt, a racist hate anthem. I am saying that many racists gladly adopted the song as a hate anthem. I am not saying that the only interpretation of the song's rural-versus-urban positioning is one of anti-black, anti-progress, pro-white messaging. I am saying that many anti-black, anti-progress, pro-white people certainly heard that message. I am not saying that Jason Aldean purposely saw the widening rift in American life between the cultural poles and decided to capitalize on that rift by weaponizing a lower-than-replacement level faux-country Three Doors Down demo. I am saying that is exactly what he did. I don't know if I've hit 100 words yet, so let me close with three thoughts: This video from Philadelphia celebrity Pat Finnerty is more or less the last word anyone needs on this song; this is a picture of the people who like this song; intentions are far less meaningful than actions, and actions are what get remembered.

1 comment:

Sara said...

omg that picture made me chuckle