Prompt: "A folk song from the '60s"
Selected by Joe
"Cod'ine"
Buffy Sainte-Marie
It's My Way!, 1964
Okay, so, Buffy Sainte-Marie. Famous Indigenous folk singer. Only really came onto my radar in the past year or so. But then a few months ago I saw a news article about some Canadian magazine attempting to claim that Sainte-Marie was in fact not Indigenous, that a significant portion of her biological lineage was white, that she had been knowingly appropriating the culture, etc. etc. I'm on marginally invested in the music, but I'm fully invested in the truth, and here is the statement that I put the most stock in. A response statement from the chief of the Piapot Nation, with whom Buffy grew up.
The emphasis is mine, because that's the most meaningful line in the statement, as far as I'm concerned. We chose her and she chose us. Man. There's power in those words. And I think they speak to a larger idea here. The idea that's weighed on my mind since reading it is one of identity. Do we get to choose our identity, or does someone choose it for us?
In Sainte-Marie's case, it actually seems like more of the latter than the former. Which is not necessarily a bad thing. She was chosen by her community to identify a certain way, and because of that identity that was chosen for her, she was given the opportunity to become the woman that she became as she grew. But maybe it's more like a balance. Right? Because she still had and has agency to be whomever she wants to be, within that context. Independence borne of dependence. She was chosen, and thus, she chose.
I think about my own life, and how stupid and ignorant it would be to say that I am where I am today totally by choice. Again, that's not necessarily a bad thing. I made decisions, sometimes important ones, that have kept me on the path that leads to now, but my point, I think, is that those decisions only existed because, at one point way before any of that, certain people made certain decisions for me. I didn't choose the family I was born into. I wasn't alive when my parents bought the house that I lived in at birth. My parents made decisions to work certain careers that allowed me to be raised with all necessities accounted for (and then some). While very young, I was taught certain ideals. Some I've embraced because I feel they are worthy guideposts to good living, and some I've worked really hard to fight against and to disavow because I've learned over time that they were wrong in such and such a way. That's a choice, but a choice that I'm only in a position to make because of previous decisions that were made for me. Independence, borne of dependence.
The entirety of Buffy Sainte-Marie's 1964 album It's My Way! (there's that independence again) is worth a listen, but I chose "Cod'ine" for thematic reasons (in addition to the fact that it's one of her more popular and well-covered songs). In it, we have our protagonist making a purposeful choice. She was prescribed codeine to treat a bronchial infection, and became addicted, to the point where her "belly is a-cravin'" and she's "got a shakin' in [her] head." Chosen: she was prescribed originally, because at this time, the addictive properties hadn't been studied thoroughly. Chosen: Indigenous communities are at higher risk of substance use disorders. Choice: something ain't right here, and I'm going to fight it.
When I think about the idea of a "folk song from the '60s," I usually think about the singers who were trying to change something within our society, the addressing of injustices, that kind of thing. And maybe that's wrong to think that; maybe that's a Boomer mentality, overhyping the music of that time out of some overblown sense of importance, and passed down to me (chosen, not choice). I don't think that through line is completely absent in "Cod'ine," but I do think that the song is less an indictment of society and more an exploration of self, which cuts against the grain (e.g. the greater-than-zero number of '60s Dylan songs chosen today, if I had to guess).
And not that holding up a mirror is something that's never been done in music, obviously. I'm just saying that there's value to this song that maybe you might not find in other songs of its time and of its genre. In it, we find the tension between the chosen and the choice. Buffy Sainte-Marie was chosen to be who she was, and she chose to continue down that path that she was set on, and I in turn am choosing to present her in a way that I feel appropriate for this quickly buried blog post. It's hard to think of our lives as all action, all choice—the appeal in the idea that Americans are special because we are "free," for instance—but it's more difficult, and probably just as important, to remember that sometimes, we cannot choose. Sometimes, the choice is made for us. We are thus shaped, not by how we act, but by how we react.
"We spent our entire lives together with Buffy as a family, decades together, and we will continue to love and support one another. She has been committed to our family and community and has worked tirelessly to inspire, support, uplift our family, and share our community knowledge and ways and those of other Indigenous Peoples all over the world... Buffy is our family. We chose her and she chose us. We claim her as a member of our family and all of our family members are from the Piapot First Nation. To us, that holds far more weight than any paper documentation or colonial record keeping ever could."
The emphasis is mine, because that's the most meaningful line in the statement, as far as I'm concerned. We chose her and she chose us. Man. There's power in those words. And I think they speak to a larger idea here. The idea that's weighed on my mind since reading it is one of identity. Do we get to choose our identity, or does someone choose it for us?
In Sainte-Marie's case, it actually seems like more of the latter than the former. Which is not necessarily a bad thing. She was chosen by her community to identify a certain way, and because of that identity that was chosen for her, she was given the opportunity to become the woman that she became as she grew. But maybe it's more like a balance. Right? Because she still had and has agency to be whomever she wants to be, within that context. Independence borne of dependence. She was chosen, and thus, she chose.
I think about my own life, and how stupid and ignorant it would be to say that I am where I am today totally by choice. Again, that's not necessarily a bad thing. I made decisions, sometimes important ones, that have kept me on the path that leads to now, but my point, I think, is that those decisions only existed because, at one point way before any of that, certain people made certain decisions for me. I didn't choose the family I was born into. I wasn't alive when my parents bought the house that I lived in at birth. My parents made decisions to work certain careers that allowed me to be raised with all necessities accounted for (and then some). While very young, I was taught certain ideals. Some I've embraced because I feel they are worthy guideposts to good living, and some I've worked really hard to fight against and to disavow because I've learned over time that they were wrong in such and such a way. That's a choice, but a choice that I'm only in a position to make because of previous decisions that were made for me. Independence, borne of dependence.
The entirety of Buffy Sainte-Marie's 1964 album It's My Way! (there's that independence again) is worth a listen, but I chose "Cod'ine" for thematic reasons (in addition to the fact that it's one of her more popular and well-covered songs). In it, we have our protagonist making a purposeful choice. She was prescribed codeine to treat a bronchial infection, and became addicted, to the point where her "belly is a-cravin'" and she's "got a shakin' in [her] head." Chosen: she was prescribed originally, because at this time, the addictive properties hadn't been studied thoroughly. Chosen: Indigenous communities are at higher risk of substance use disorders. Choice: something ain't right here, and I'm going to fight it.
When I think about the idea of a "folk song from the '60s," I usually think about the singers who were trying to change something within our society, the addressing of injustices, that kind of thing. And maybe that's wrong to think that; maybe that's a Boomer mentality, overhyping the music of that time out of some overblown sense of importance, and passed down to me (chosen, not choice). I don't think that through line is completely absent in "Cod'ine," but I do think that the song is less an indictment of society and more an exploration of self, which cuts against the grain (e.g. the greater-than-zero number of '60s Dylan songs chosen today, if I had to guess).
And not that holding up a mirror is something that's never been done in music, obviously. I'm just saying that there's value to this song that maybe you might not find in other songs of its time and of its genre. In it, we find the tension between the chosen and the choice. Buffy Sainte-Marie was chosen to be who she was, and she chose to continue down that path that she was set on, and I in turn am choosing to present her in a way that I feel appropriate for this quickly buried blog post. It's hard to think of our lives as all action, all choice—the appeal in the idea that Americans are special because we are "free," for instance—but it's more difficult, and probably just as important, to remember that sometimes, we cannot choose. Sometimes, the choice is made for us. We are thus shaped, not by how we act, but by how we react.
No comments:
Post a Comment