Friday, May 13, 2022

Thats What They All Say, Nate


You could complicate Jack Harlow, if you wanted to, in the way that all conversations about white rappers are inherently complicated. There's likewise a sticky discussion to be had about the notions of urban versus suburban contexts in rap music; about where the music comes from, who the music is for, what the cadence and delivery and timber and presentation of the music does to subvert or highlight the pretexts and pretenses of both audience and artist. There's a less politically-charged, but still murky conversation to be had about intentionality of songcraft in a music consumption landscape propelled (decreasingly) by playlist ubiquity on streaming services and (increasingly) by social media penetration. Harlow makes for a compelling text in any of these instances, as he sits at the bleeding intersection of racial, political, commercial and market forces in the same way all pop stars do.

Let's simplify it. Jack Harlow is making Drake songs, potentially Drake songs specifically for teens (count the references to high school). If the past twelve years of rap have proven anything, it's that you can grab a little something if you do nothing more than make Drake songs with some level of proficiency. You can grab a little more if you do it with style. Grant Harlow at least that. Grant also that he does a pretty good job on the "Whats Poppin" remix.

This is a record that invites snark. I will avoid it except to say the following: on "Tyler Herro," Harlow leads the track addressing the racial component of his popularity by saying "The ones that hate me the most look just like me / you tell me what that means." Here's the answer: you can't be loved or hated by people who aren't listening.

One more note: Lil Baby raps his ass off in his 30 seconds on this album, once again out-rapping a Drake-type on their own song, and DaBaby raps his ass off on the "Whats Poppin" remix in the way he has consistently rapped his ass off for the past three years. If you have additional questions about my stance on DaBaby, please see this song by Drug Church.

No comments: