Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #18 and is featured on pages 131-135.
"Martha My Dear"
The White Album
1968
There was no obligation to pull triple duty today on the blog, and yet it made sense thematically—there was some dogsitting going on at our house this week, and this is a Beatles song about a dog. You'll get to read the really ugly and self-hating side of my experiences with the dog at our house a little later, when Thirsty Thursday is published the start of happy hour. For now, you get to read about Paul McCartney's fucking sheepdog.
It's definitely a surprise seeing "Martha My Dear" all the way up here at #18. I always considered it a bit of a White Album deep cut (even with the term "deep cut" being used loosely in the context of the single-less White Album). But I back the choice by the authors here. It's nice seeing them being subjective for once instead of saying cliché bullshit like "Beatlemaniacs everywhere love this song!!" or any such nonsense.
The truth: Steve loves the song, Mike is ambivalent, and apparently Steve put his foot down. Apparently, Steve Spignesi spent a lot of time learning how to play "Martha My Dear" on piano, and his love of the song grew through repetition. I don't agree with him, but I make a full-throated commitment to the idea that music is subjective and that we love what we love due to personal experience. The fact that I personally did not take the time to learn "Martha My Dear" on the piano should not disqualify it from adoration by someone who can actually play the piano and wanted to write a book about the songs that he loves.
So that's fun. What's less fun is the fact that more than zero people have mentioned this song in the context of my middle child's name being in the title of this song. Besides the fact that I would never name my child after a Beatles song (no judgment if that's your thing, though), there's also the implication that you are comparing my daughter to a fucking dog, which is insulting on at least two levels (the second being that you were ignorant enough about Beatles lore to not even know that you were talking about a song about a dog in the first place).
Interestingly, the book mentions the possibility that "Martha My Dear" is not actually about Martha the sheepdog, but simply named after the dog in question. In other words, the dog is a metaphor, and when Paul sings "You've always been my inspiration," he's not literally talking about a fucking dog. In some ways, it would probably have been better if we didn't know about the dog at all, even beyond the fact that all dogs are disgusting creatures of death. I just spoke about this last time re: "Blackbird," how it's easier for the listener to shape the song in their own image if the artist doesn't put too much of their own personal stamp on its background and meaning. Not saying there can't be fun songs about dogs, but I struggle to find any empathy in a person who gets all their "inspiration" from a hideous heartless four-legged nose-biter.
That's certainly not to say that this is a bad song. Ignore the is-it-about-a-dog-or-not of it all, and you get a pretty neat Beatles song. I like how the book describes it as a "concerto," since it has orchestral flair and three distinct movements. I feel like I take the orchestra stuff for granted when it comes to the Beatles, but this is some pretty intense stuff, when you really think about it. I love when the rhythm breaks in half and the trumpets pick up the melody. I guess I never would've noticed the tempo switch (4/4 to 3/2 and then back to 4/4) if the book hadn't pointed it out, so that's cool. And I've always appreciated the bass guitar on this song. Something about the the bounciness and the way is goes down the scale during that bridge has stuck with me all these years. It's a weird choice in terms of "best bass songs," but I'm sticking by it.
I guess that's it for today. I'm really only hear so I can vomit up all my thoughts about dogs in one single day, and then never mentioned the D-word ever again for as long as I live. Paul, what were you thinking, man?!
BEATLES TRIVIA: It seems like every single song write-up in this book makes mention of an interview that John Lennon did with Playboy. Are they all referring to a single interview? Or was Lennon so bored in the '70s that he had time to speak with a porno mag on a weekly basis? In any case, the Playboy interview(s) get(s) mentioned for "Martha My Dear," in that allegedly John Lennon had very little to say about it since he hated it. Allegedly. "Enough said" was his actual pithy remark, and I think the authors are right to assume that it was a dismissal of "Martha My Dear." Look, I don't think it's the eighteenth-best Beatles song or anything, but I also think it's a swell track. I get the feeling that Lennon ascribes to the "the song is about a fucking dog?" theory, and that's why he went so negative on it. I get the impulse, John, I do, but unfortunately you're wrong here.
BETTER BEATLE: A significantly large portion of Side 2 of the White Album is made up of animal songs. Here are PoYB's definitive rankings of the four animal songs on this quarter of the best Beatles album of all time: 1) "Rocky Racoon"; 2) "Martha My Dear"; 3) "Blackbird"; 4) "Piggies." Incredibly, "Rocky Racoon" did not make this Top 100 list. But neither did the truly awful "Piggies," so I guess it all evens out.
NEXT TIME: "I Feel Fine" at #19
NEXT TIME: "I Feel Fine" at #19
1 comment:
I initially jumped in here to proclaim my utter shock that THIS SONG is at number 18, it’s simply not a great song, certainly not top 20. Before I go any deeper, and I realize this was written a long time ago, but that Lennon Playboy interview is from 1980, available in book form. “All We Are Saying” David Sheff. Highly recommend. Also “Beatles Songs” by William Dowlding which is my personal bible, and what I will reference when reading through this list.
Post a Comment