I'm doing the work, and getting nowhere. A lot of darkness here. Please shine the light in this direction right here. What to make of this loud, messy, scraggly, fuzzy, convexing, powerful album. I don't know. I read around the interweb, and saw a description that stood out, for maybe the wrong reasons: "this is like the Hold Steady without the fun and games." I see the truth in this description. I read it as a criticism. But I also think that maaaaaaybe that's the point here? That there's no fun and games to be had? And that maybe there is more truth in that mindset than there is in having fun drinking and smoking in the Party Pit?
I am at once fascinated and completely perplexed by the unknowable sprawl of the Canadian tundra. Insert Degrassi joke here. But that essential teen soap takes place in the metropolis of Toronto, and that's not what I'm talking about here. I'm talking about the frozen wastelands on the outskirts of those cities. I find them mysterious and bewildering, and if we're saying that Shine a Light is a testament to their secrets, then it make sense that it doesn't make sense. If that makes sense.
It isn't for me, but in some respects it is for me. "Young Lions" is the big song for a reason. "Springsteenian" is a made-up adjective that totally applies here. It was noted that Brian Fallon of the Gaslight Anthem has a "Young Lions" tattoo, and if you're connecting the dots in the appropriate fashion, then we're starting to get the bigger picture here. Some of these sounds are stuck in the Yukon, but some are alive within all former teenagers, hearts ablaze, that feeling that you own the world and can't be contained. That's there in "Young Lions," and elsewhere on Shine a Light, if you go searching for it, if you can survive the sub-freezing temps.
The idea of "Canada" gets thrown around a lot, on this blog and elsewhere, in relation to Constantines, and that's not really our fault. It's a symptom of living our formative years through the mid-'00s, when Canada had a big moment in the center of indie rock. Wolf Parade and Broken Social Scene and the other band that I won't mention here, all huge Canadian acts that managed to find their way into our lives in a big way. Well, I don't want to speak for my generation here, so let's just say: me. These are and were important bands to me.
There are plenty of moments throughout Shine a Light where I can place this band within that context, despite twenty years gone by. The surprisingly sprightly chorus of "On to You," the chaotic intro to the title track, "Scoundrel Babes" attempting to make a fist-in-the-air anthem as discordant as possible and intentionally failing. But there are other times when I'm discovering something new, a new feeling or emotion or something, and my vision gets all cloudy and I just can't fucking imagine that I would have ever grasped this music during those teenage years. It's tough to think back on those times objectively but I honestly don't think that I would've considered Constantines one of the holy Canadians of their time.
Maybe it's the voice. Great vocals, but only in this context. Objectively bad, subjectively amazing. The sandpaper singing works but also represents something more, something closer to those ideas of snow and ice Up North that I mentioned a moment ago. This is a singer that has seen some shit, ya feel me? He's singing from somewhere deep and dark, and sometimes I just find myself pushing away, just a tiny bit. Probably because I'm scared. I don't like the dark. I don't like not knowing. I cannot possibly relate, here, as I sit in 90-degree weather in the heart of the fifth-largest city in Canada's shitty southern cousin.
That's totally cool. I'd be fooling myself if I assumed that I could possibly know everything there is to know. I can also like something without knowing it. I like Shine a Light—and occasionally, I like it a lot—but I feel a certain distance between us, one that I will never traverse, ever, no matter how hard I try or how far I leap. But there is a thrill in the attempt, at least. A certain satisfaction is exploring something hitherto completely and utterly unknown, at least until the moment you freeze to death.
The idea of "Canada" gets thrown around a lot, on this blog and elsewhere, in relation to Constantines, and that's not really our fault. It's a symptom of living our formative years through the mid-'00s, when Canada had a big moment in the center of indie rock. Wolf Parade and Broken Social Scene and the other band that I won't mention here, all huge Canadian acts that managed to find their way into our lives in a big way. Well, I don't want to speak for my generation here, so let's just say: me. These are and were important bands to me.
There are plenty of moments throughout Shine a Light where I can place this band within that context, despite twenty years gone by. The surprisingly sprightly chorus of "On to You," the chaotic intro to the title track, "Scoundrel Babes" attempting to make a fist-in-the-air anthem as discordant as possible and intentionally failing. But there are other times when I'm discovering something new, a new feeling or emotion or something, and my vision gets all cloudy and I just can't fucking imagine that I would have ever grasped this music during those teenage years. It's tough to think back on those times objectively but I honestly don't think that I would've considered Constantines one of the holy Canadians of their time.
Maybe it's the voice. Great vocals, but only in this context. Objectively bad, subjectively amazing. The sandpaper singing works but also represents something more, something closer to those ideas of snow and ice Up North that I mentioned a moment ago. This is a singer that has seen some shit, ya feel me? He's singing from somewhere deep and dark, and sometimes I just find myself pushing away, just a tiny bit. Probably because I'm scared. I don't like the dark. I don't like not knowing. I cannot possibly relate, here, as I sit in 90-degree weather in the heart of the fifth-largest city in Canada's shitty southern cousin.
That's totally cool. I'd be fooling myself if I assumed that I could possibly know everything there is to know. I can also like something without knowing it. I like Shine a Light—and occasionally, I like it a lot—but I feel a certain distance between us, one that I will never traverse, ever, no matter how hard I try or how far I leap. But there is a thrill in the attempt, at least. A certain satisfaction is exploring something hitherto completely and utterly unknown, at least until the moment you freeze to death.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment