See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.
1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
As a captain, I feel there are really only two worthwhile strategies: pick something that could appeal broadly and still be interesting, or get fully into one's own bag and pick shit for yourself. I went with option B and have no regrets.
As a captain, I feel there are really only two worthwhile strategies: pick something that could appeal broadly and still be interesting, or get fully into one's own bag and pick shit for yourself. I went with option B and have no regrets.
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Samey this week. Most people landed on "it's fine." Love's opposite is not hate but apathy, so Sam's mid-uber screed comes closest to a pan and also shields itself from engagement from a lunatic like me because you cannot argue with someone who doesn't care.
Samey this week. Most people landed on "it's fine." Love's opposite is not hate but apathy, so Sam's mid-uber screed comes closest to a pan and also shields itself from engagement from a lunatic like me because you cannot argue with someone who doesn't care.
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
No, but that's the point of picking an album you love, I think, is testing your own views against the steel and forge of others. I will say that many of you had more time for "Scoundrel Babes" than I ever had.
No, but that's the point of picking an album you love, I think, is testing your own views against the steel and forge of others. I will say that many of you had more time for "Scoundrel Babes" than I ever had.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
The easiest thing to write about are the lyrics, and no one really took a crack at them. I was surprised by that. The second-easiest thing is probably Bry Webb's voice, which I will accept no judgement or criticism of, Joe, you mealy-mouthed half-stepper. The third easiest thing is the rhythm section, which Pam found good ground on.
The easiest thing to write about are the lyrics, and no one really took a crack at them. I was surprised by that. The second-easiest thing is probably Bry Webb's voice, which I will accept no judgement or criticism of, Joe, you mealy-mouthed half-stepper. The third easiest thing is the rhythm section, which Pam found good ground on.
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
Not regret, exactly, but you cannot make people care about what you care about by forcing it onto them. It's fine, I am secure in the knowledge that Craig Finn, Brian Fallon, the dudes from Restorations, every Canadian rock band, Laura Jane Grace, Niko Stratis, and I are on the right side of history. Gary, too. Hell fuckin' yeah, brother.
Not regret, exactly, but you cannot make people care about what you care about by forcing it onto them. It's fine, I am secure in the knowledge that Craig Finn, Brian Fallon, the dudes from Restorations, every Canadian rock band, Laura Jane Grace, Niko Stratis, and I are on the right side of history. Gary, too. Hell fuckin' yeah, brother.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
Songs from the record, tiered:
POST-HARDCORE TRADITIONALISTS ONLY TIER
- "Tiger & Crane"
- "National Hum"
- "Scoundrel Babes"
VERY GOOD ROCK SONG TIER
- "Goodbye Baby & Amen"
- "Poison"
- "Young Lions"
EXCEPTIONALLY GOOD ROCK SONG TIER
- "Tank Commander (Hung Up in a Warehouse Town)"
- "Insectivora"
- "Shine a Light"
- "Sub-Domestic"
HOLY BLESSED WORD FROM THE GOD OF ETERNAL YOUTH HIMSELF
- "On to You"
- "Nighttime / Anytime (It's Alright)"
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
Someone else write these reviews for me.

No comments:
Post a Comment