Prompt: "A song by someone who was born after September 11, 2001"
Selected by Joe
"Remember"
The Linda Lindas
Growing Up, 2022
Some prompts have been harder than others, but I think that this one has been the one that's given me the most trouble in the past 63 days. I don't want it to mean what I think that it means—that I'm "too old for this shit." Even though it's probably true. I went through most of my iPod, and the only artists that I could pinpoint as under the age of 22 on sight were Billie Eilish and Olivia Rodrigo. Their respective debut albums are on there more out of obligation than anything. I'm sure a couple songs from these artists will pop up today, and I'll listen to them and probably enjoy them too. But I have trouble connecting with them on an emotional level.
I feel like I have this knee-jerk reaction to disliking music that is made by artists who are this young. Occasionally I feel like they are speaking a language I don't understand, and if you don't check yourself constantly, then you start to fear what you don't understand. I want to like and understand and appreciate and emotionally connect with music from all kinds of artists, including the very young ones. But so far—unless I'm forgetting someone—I have yet to connect that deeply with any music that anyone born after September 11th has ever released.
So when I chose a song from the Linda Lindas today, I did so because I think their music is swell, and because they are really fucking young (four members, ages as old as eighteen and as young as twelve). And I listened to this album in full like three or four times, and managed to pick out my favorite one out of the ten (and avoided "Racist Sexist Boy," which is their most famous song and also by far their worst). I think if you're listening to all the songs for today in a row, "Remember" isn't going to be an outlier of any sort. It's not going to stand out, either. It's just your standard rock song performed by some talented young women.
I will share with you now that, at the end of the day, I don't really like this. That was my first reaction and it remains my current reaction. Something about it seems shallow to me. Maybe that reaction is not fair. It's at least worth examining. Because I know there are a lot of people out there who are instantly dismissive of the Linda Lindas for nefarious reasons, and I don't want to be lumped in with them. I don't want to be a racist, sexist boy. (Though you'll note that all the artists that I've named in this blog post so far are women. Hmm.)
Usually, when a young woman is coming up in the "alt" scene, or "rock" scene," or "indie" scene, or however you fucking describe it these days (I'm mainly talking about non-pop music here), there are instantly complaints about this artist being an "industry plant" or a "nepo baby" or something along those lines. I've seen it constantly about every young female indie artist whose music I've ever loved. I think people on the internet out there are still asking loud questions about what Phoebe Bridgers' dad does for a living, as if that makes a difference if the music is tight.
But I guess it's worth examining when it comes to the Linda Lindas, even if it's just to rule it out. The Wikipedia page on this band is pretty explicit about the members' connections to the music industry. Two of the Lindas are sisters and their father is Carlos de la Garza, a music producer. One of the Lindas is their cousin, and that Linda's father is Martin Wong, co-founder of the Asian-American arts and culture magazine Giant Robot. They were able to get some gigs pretty quickly in part because they are talented, but also in part because their families are well-connected in the industry. Note that Carlos de la Garza has been mentioned on this blog before as the producer of Paramore's recent album This Is Why. Then note that the Linda Lindas are the opening band on Paramore's tour this summer.
The family connection doesn't disqualify the Linda Lindas from earning their keep on the road, and I would like to think that Paramore would be in the position to decline the request if they didn't think the Linda Lindas were a good band. But I also don't think that we should pretend that their rapidly accelerated rise through the industry ranks automatically proves that there is something special about the Linda Lindas. Based on merit alone, I say: they are not bad. Probably some more deserving bands that should be opening for Paramore, but what can ya do.
And, like, maybe we shouldn't expect them to be all that special right now? There's still so much time. They're all teenagers, for christ's sake. The drummer isn't even a teenager yet! I'm trying to picture my nine-year-old niece playing drums for a nationally touring rock band in three years, and I honestly can't do it. It's insane that they are already being considered a legitimate musical act. Well, not "insane" as in "unlikely," since we already discussed the quasi-nepotism. More like "insane" as in "I can't believe how young they are." The more I think about it, the more I believe that this is the entire sales pitch for the Linda Lindas. "It's just like any other generic punk rock band, except the kids are young as shit!" There's commercial value there, but not necessarily artistic value.
So at the end of the day, I believe that I was correct in mostly dismissing this band. But what I'm worried about is that knee-jerk dismissal is going to become the natural practice for me. And it shouldn't be! I need to be able to trust that, as I get older, and as the age gap between myself and the youngest popular musicians I know about widens, that I'll remain open to the possibility of being wowed by a post-9/11 baby. Because if I don't watch myself, then I'll wake up one day, and EVERY popular musician is going to be significantly younger than me, and at the point the skepticism and cynicism will be too much to bear.
And who knows! Maybe I'll even find that artist today! You never know! Either that, or we'll get seven more Olivia Rodrigo songs! Doesn't matter! I'm here. I'm open. I'm willing to give it a try.
So when I chose a song from the Linda Lindas today, I did so because I think their music is swell, and because they are really fucking young (four members, ages as old as eighteen and as young as twelve). And I listened to this album in full like three or four times, and managed to pick out my favorite one out of the ten (and avoided "Racist Sexist Boy," which is their most famous song and also by far their worst). I think if you're listening to all the songs for today in a row, "Remember" isn't going to be an outlier of any sort. It's not going to stand out, either. It's just your standard rock song performed by some talented young women.
I will share with you now that, at the end of the day, I don't really like this. That was my first reaction and it remains my current reaction. Something about it seems shallow to me. Maybe that reaction is not fair. It's at least worth examining. Because I know there are a lot of people out there who are instantly dismissive of the Linda Lindas for nefarious reasons, and I don't want to be lumped in with them. I don't want to be a racist, sexist boy. (Though you'll note that all the artists that I've named in this blog post so far are women. Hmm.)
Usually, when a young woman is coming up in the "alt" scene, or "rock" scene," or "indie" scene, or however you fucking describe it these days (I'm mainly talking about non-pop music here), there are instantly complaints about this artist being an "industry plant" or a "nepo baby" or something along those lines. I've seen it constantly about every young female indie artist whose music I've ever loved. I think people on the internet out there are still asking loud questions about what Phoebe Bridgers' dad does for a living, as if that makes a difference if the music is tight.
But I guess it's worth examining when it comes to the Linda Lindas, even if it's just to rule it out. The Wikipedia page on this band is pretty explicit about the members' connections to the music industry. Two of the Lindas are sisters and their father is Carlos de la Garza, a music producer. One of the Lindas is their cousin, and that Linda's father is Martin Wong, co-founder of the Asian-American arts and culture magazine Giant Robot. They were able to get some gigs pretty quickly in part because they are talented, but also in part because their families are well-connected in the industry. Note that Carlos de la Garza has been mentioned on this blog before as the producer of Paramore's recent album This Is Why. Then note that the Linda Lindas are the opening band on Paramore's tour this summer.
The family connection doesn't disqualify the Linda Lindas from earning their keep on the road, and I would like to think that Paramore would be in the position to decline the request if they didn't think the Linda Lindas were a good band. But I also don't think that we should pretend that their rapidly accelerated rise through the industry ranks automatically proves that there is something special about the Linda Lindas. Based on merit alone, I say: they are not bad. Probably some more deserving bands that should be opening for Paramore, but what can ya do.
And, like, maybe we shouldn't expect them to be all that special right now? There's still so much time. They're all teenagers, for christ's sake. The drummer isn't even a teenager yet! I'm trying to picture my nine-year-old niece playing drums for a nationally touring rock band in three years, and I honestly can't do it. It's insane that they are already being considered a legitimate musical act. Well, not "insane" as in "unlikely," since we already discussed the quasi-nepotism. More like "insane" as in "I can't believe how young they are." The more I think about it, the more I believe that this is the entire sales pitch for the Linda Lindas. "It's just like any other generic punk rock band, except the kids are young as shit!" There's commercial value there, but not necessarily artistic value.
So at the end of the day, I believe that I was correct in mostly dismissing this band. But what I'm worried about is that knee-jerk dismissal is going to become the natural practice for me. And it shouldn't be! I need to be able to trust that, as I get older, and as the age gap between myself and the youngest popular musicians I know about widens, that I'll remain open to the possibility of being wowed by a post-9/11 baby. Because if I don't watch myself, then I'll wake up one day, and EVERY popular musician is going to be significantly younger than me, and at the point the skepticism and cynicism will be too much to bear.
And who knows! Maybe I'll even find that artist today! You never know! Either that, or we'll get seven more Olivia Rodrigo songs! Doesn't matter! I'm here. I'm open. I'm willing to give it a try.
No comments:
Post a Comment