You know the deal: insiders are allowed to critique, and outsiders can back the fuck off. It's like how Philadelphians are really tough on their own city, and are quick to name its numerous faults, but then if some fucking asshole from New York tries to say something bad about our city, then they get their fucking head ripped off. How dare you talk shit about our city, the best city on earth?! It's the same with RuPaul and Drag Race and drag in general. Not that I'm an "insider," but I have watched the past six seasons of Drag Race (main series and All Stars), and so I'm definitely at least fractionally familiar with the art of drag at this point, enough that I feel comfortable talking about the negatives, of which there are many, especially when it comes to the music specifically. But if someone is gonna come over here and start ignorantly talking shit about drag queens, or spout talking points from Fox News or some shit, well, then we have a problem.
It pisses me off on two levels. The first is that the war against drag is an obvious and pathetic attempt to push through an agenda of hate. There are lies about "grooming" and all that shit, and they are lies because not one drag queen has ever committed that type of crime against a child. No, that would be priests and youth ministers, thousands of sex crimes every year that are conveniently ignored by the side of the aisle that claims that they want to "protect the children." It's all bullshit. If you consider yourself a conservative: fuck you, get off this blog.
Sorry, sorry, I get worked up with this kind of shit, as you've no doubt noticed. It's not really responsible of me to get like that, since I am also not the most informed person regarding this subject and others, and I want to be a good ally, but just getting angry and spitting vitriol in an album review probably isn't the best way to do it. On a personal level, I want to stay humble and curious, and angrily shouting at people and acting like I know everything is totally opposite of those two virtues.
So, the second level that it pisses me off is something that I feel like I have more authority to speak about. I'm talking about music. And it pisses me off that, because some fucking cowards think it's a good idea to bring guns to a Drag Queen Story Time event, I have to play defense in a fucking music review created by the most famous drag queen in the country. It muddles my opinions, because now there's a responsibility to consider the harm I'm doing when I talk about how shitty and cheap and lazy some of RuPaul's songs are. Yes, there's a huge gap between me (who thinks that the music created by drag queens whom he sees on the TV is in general pretty terrible) and conservatives (who think that anyone who considers themselves part of the LGBTQ community should be dead), but not everyone can distinguish the two. And so I either have to not say anything negative at all, or take way too much time in overexplaining the situation. I'm choosing the latter, obviously, but it's such a pain in the ass. I thought I was promised "fun" this week?!
It's been documented a few times already that I think the music on Drag Race is cringeworthy at best, and at its worst literally the most terrible music that's ever been made by anyone. I'm talking about the "original songs," by the way, though the song choices for the lip syncs could be better too (says a lot that there's a Lizzo song at least once a season). Anyone hear Monica Beverly Hillz's song during the Fame Games talent show last Friday? It was no joke the worst piece of music I've ever heard in my entire life. I think Monica Beverly Hillz is beautiful and talented, and as a music critic I think she's an affront to this form of entertainment that I care so much about. Whenever a queen on the show indicates that they are performing an original song, my whole body sort of seizes up, and I anticipate the worst. They usually follow through with that worst. So it goes.
I guess I'm setting the scene this way to let you know how impossibly low my expectations were for RuPaul's 2017 opus, American. Which was a mildly stupid thing to think, since RuPaul is clearly more talented (and, let's be real, has access to a lot more resources) than a lot of these reality show schlubs. She's the Babe Ruth of drag. Of course she's going to be hitting more dingers than even the top talents of the current generation.
Doesn't mean American is a great album, but it's at least fun in some sections, memorable in others, overall really polished and exudes surface-level competence, and best of all, keeps the cringe to a minimum. Yeah, I know this is basically karaoke with songs you didn't already know. Like, I kept picturing those singing challenges that happen once or twice a season, when they have Leland attempt to instruct the queens on how to record their sections of the medley, and imagined that this album was recorded under similar circumstances. I picture Ru in the studio, being handed a sheet of music, being told my a Leland-type figure to "sing it this way," and (unlike many of the Drag Race contestants) nailing every part on the first try. My point being that this isn't RuPaul sitting down in the studio and being like "I'm going to create a song that sounds like a really fun Shania Twain pastiche" and then tinkering with all the instruments until she comes up with "Lady Cowboy." It's more that RuPaul has the talent and personality to confidently put on the "musician" hat whenever she feels like it (i.e. whenever there's a new season of Drag Race coming up) by surrounding herself with actual musicians.
The songs are paper thin, but they're more or less fun. There are a few hooks on this thing that the rest of the light and fluffy album can totally hang on. Off the top of my head, I'm thinking about the "boogie body rockin' queen" section of "Kitty Girl," and the parts of "Broke Me Down" that sound like Ru attempting Squarepusher, and also pretty much all of the very "Islands in the Stream"-esque "It Ain't Over." There are some pretty terrible sections too. "From the Clintons to the Obamas" is an even more cringeworthy line than Lake Street Dive's Obama reference, remember that?! And I get the sense that everyone involved in Drag Race thinks that the C.U.N.T. acronym is way more clever than it actually is. But none of that is bad enough that I'm totally turned off by American. It's okay. It's fine. It's even good sometimes.
It's probably helpful not to take it too seriously, but only because I get the sense that RuPaul doesn't take it all that seriously either. I mean, there's a reason that she laughs the hardest during the roast episodes when one of the queens takes a crack at her music career (sidenote: my absolute favorite part of RuPaul is her laugh, and I regret that it didn't make the cut for American). She had a hit in the early '90s, but at this point is pretty much using music as fodder for her TV show. Fine, whatever.
My usual m.o. here is that I take music seriously, but I'm giving that a break this week, because I don't think the music calls for it. I'd be doing a disservice to a community that is being threatened right now by cretins who work tireless toward this community's demise. I look forward to listening to real, actual, serious music for the rest of our Record Club summer, yes. But it wasn't really that hard to grin and bear it this week either. I grin and bear it every single week with Drag Race. Because that's important! It's important to support this community of artists, and every community of artists, especially when they are under fire, and drag queens are absolutely under fire right now. I'm taking a stand by not making too much of a stink of it this week. You do your thing, Mama Ru. I got your back.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment