Prompt: "A song about a pet"
Selected by Joe
"Fanny Dog"
Ty Segall
Freedom's Goblin, 2018
I read an article recently that postulates that the very act of pet ownership in and of itself constitutes pet abuse. In other words, if you own a dog, you are abusing that dog. I don't even think the article was arguing that we should abolish pet ownership—since arguing about something that would never in a million years happen seems like a waste of time—but was instead arguing that people should think on it before they commit to the awesome (and ultimately futile) responsibility of taking care of a pet. And the big underlined point was that an emotional need for dogs is companionship, and so if you own a dog and you're also working a full-time job outside of your home, then that's abuse, or at the very least neglect. If you're going to call your dog "another member of the family," then you have to consider whether you'd leave, say, your five-year-old daughter home, alone, with no stimulation, five days a week, for months on end. If that answer is "no," then maybe think long and hard about whether you want to add that dog to your family in the first place.
I appreciated the article mainly because I'm a shit-stirrer, and I think it's funny to present this argument to pet owners. I don't really have any strong feelings about animals one way or the other. My family had a dog named Mollie growing up, and I stayed out of the whole cliché thing where the kids would say "we'll take care of it!" and then not take care of it and allow that responsibility to fall on the parents—that was all my sisters, I never made one single fucking claim that I would care for Mollie, and I never did. Not my pet, not my problem. After she passed away in 2009, my parents got Chloe, a much smaller dog but a much bigger annoyance, with her literal dogshit breath and a tendency to bring slugs into the home (and occasionally onto my bed). Chloe is still kicking, and my kids think she's a hoot, but I feel the same void of emotion that I would any other pet.
I don't like dogs in general. I'm already on the record about that, and nothing has changed in the nine months since I wrote the anti-dog screed. I don't like them because they provide a palpable threat toward my family, a threat that has been proven both scientifically and anecdotally. In a vacuum, I feel nothing toward dogs, or really animals in general. I think some pets, including dogs, could be considered "cute," but in the same way that anything could be considered cute—a painting, a bedroom, a sundress, a song. I don't feel a need to protect them or care for them. They are wild animals that are just barely domesticated. I don't support dog fighting, but mainly because I feel icky about unnecessary violence, not because I believe in "animal rights" or whatever. I think vegetarianism and veganism are great, maybe even essential—not because of the animals, who gives a shit about them, but because being a vegan is one of the absolute best things you can do to effect positive change for the environment.
It's possible that this means there's something wrong with me, like there's a dark spot on my heart that allows other, more normal people to enjoy "caring for" dogs. It's also possible that it is YOU who are the problem, you, society in general, that we as a human race have duped ourselves into thinking that having dogs as pets is a good thing, whereas really it's doing those dogs you claim to care so much about a true disservice and causing irreparable damage and sadistic emotional and psychological harm.
Haha, nah, I'm just joking. Or am I.
I appreciated the article mainly because I'm a shit-stirrer, and I think it's funny to present this argument to pet owners. I don't really have any strong feelings about animals one way or the other. My family had a dog named Mollie growing up, and I stayed out of the whole cliché thing where the kids would say "we'll take care of it!" and then not take care of it and allow that responsibility to fall on the parents—that was all my sisters, I never made one single fucking claim that I would care for Mollie, and I never did. Not my pet, not my problem. After she passed away in 2009, my parents got Chloe, a much smaller dog but a much bigger annoyance, with her literal dogshit breath and a tendency to bring slugs into the home (and occasionally onto my bed). Chloe is still kicking, and my kids think she's a hoot, but I feel the same void of emotion that I would any other pet.
I don't like dogs in general. I'm already on the record about that, and nothing has changed in the nine months since I wrote the anti-dog screed. I don't like them because they provide a palpable threat toward my family, a threat that has been proven both scientifically and anecdotally. In a vacuum, I feel nothing toward dogs, or really animals in general. I think some pets, including dogs, could be considered "cute," but in the same way that anything could be considered cute—a painting, a bedroom, a sundress, a song. I don't feel a need to protect them or care for them. They are wild animals that are just barely domesticated. I don't support dog fighting, but mainly because I feel icky about unnecessary violence, not because I believe in "animal rights" or whatever. I think vegetarianism and veganism are great, maybe even essential—not because of the animals, who gives a shit about them, but because being a vegan is one of the absolute best things you can do to effect positive change for the environment.
It's possible that this means there's something wrong with me, like there's a dark spot on my heart that allows other, more normal people to enjoy "caring for" dogs. It's also possible that it is YOU who are the problem, you, society in general, that we as a human race have duped ourselves into thinking that having dogs as pets is a good thing, whereas really it's doing those dogs you claim to care so much about a true disservice and causing irreparable damage and sadistic emotional and psychological harm.
Haha, nah, I'm just joking. Or am I.
No comments:
Post a Comment