A Complete Ranking of All 40 Items on the Erstwhile McNally's Menu
40. Steak Sandwich — Either you ordered a cheesesteak without the goddamn cheese, or Iggy had been drinking since he opened up shop at 7 AM and forgot to add the cheese. Either way—fuck you!!!!!
39. Homemade Soup — Look, we used to go to McNally's at least once a week. I loved it there. This was my bar. There was a time when I could walk into McNally's on Rhawn and I knew every single person in the place. And in all my years there, I never saw anyone order the soup.
38. Pick-n-Peel Shrimp — You've been there in the AM hours, I mean like the first AM hours of the day, like 11 AM, you've been there then, you've smelled the bleach... and you still wanna order seafood?
37. Homemade Chili — It's been years, but I can still smell the bathroom. I can still close my eyes and picture myself in there, that weird mix of ammonia and piss and crushed ice and spilled beer and heavy NEast boy cologne. I've pissed in there, and I've thrown up in there, and I've survived, but I still don't envy anyone who ever had to take a shit in there. So, no to the chili.
36. Chicken Fingers — There used to be two guys who worked at Moonstruck across the street who would come over after their shift to drink cheap beers and run the shuffleboard table. One guy looked like Dave Chappelle. The other guy looked like John C. Reilly. It always felt super weird. Like, this bar is filled with mostly young 20-somethings, and now for the final 90 minutes of the night we have to kowtow to these fucking adults and pretend like they are friends and let them take the shuffleboard table? I wonder what every happened to these guys. Probably annoying some kids at another shit bar in the Northeast.
35. Onion Rings — This definitely wasn't one of those bars where it was like, "Oh, there's the owner, Mr. McNally" or some shit like that. Among my friend group at least, there was always the question of: "Wait, so who owns this bar?" There was a married couple who was always there bartending, and I guess the rumor/half-truth was that they owned the bar? Or maybe this is one of those things that has been confirmed for me multiple times at McNally's, but, ya know, I was at McNally's, and so I don't really remember...
34. Mozzarella Sticks — Anyways, I saw this couple a few years later as they were walking out of court with their divorce lawyer, so perhaps it can be said that McNally's is not a matchmaker in any sense of the word.
33. Loaded Potato Skins — Who owns McNally's now? In the great Northeast Philadelphia Telephone Game, I have been informed that two guys—one of whom is a sibling of one of my sister's friends—bought it from the interim (post-my-era) owner slightly pre-pandemic, and then recently sold it? Or put it up for sale? I don't know anything besides the fact that it hasn't been open since around February 2020 and that the light has been on in the kitchen for this entire time.
32. "Hot" Smackers — Gotta realize how dumb the Northeast is when they use quotation marks in place of italics. Well, are the smackers hot or not? And what the fuck is a smacker?!
31. Chicken Steak Sandwich — Yo, fuck the McNally's DJ.
30. Specialty Fries — The special ingredient? Yup, you guessed it: cum.
29. Chili Cheese Burger — There was happy hour, and then there were also beer specials during sports games, which was convenient, since there is rarely a night when all four Philadelphia sports teams have the night off (sidenote: I don't think the Union was part of this deal, but I could be wrong). $2 Miller and Bud pints? I mean, even less than a decade later, that already seems pretty cheap. It wasn't $5/cup, but it provided a nice little transition from drinking in the woods to drinking at a bar.
28. Shrimp in a Basket — I suppose shots were usually done most nights as well. I remember when we first started going to McNally's, Kev was the only one with a full-time job, so he was the one buying shots for everyone. That lasted a couple weeks. We'd usually order Washington Apples or Sweet Tea shots, I think. Don't ask me the ingredients to either of those.
27. Buffalo Shrimp — McNally's was the first bar I ever legally drank at during the PM hours, on December 1st, 2009. I specify "PM hours" because at 12 AM the night prior, we walked into the Rockledge Pub for a couple drinks. But McNally's is the bar I consider my first "real" bar experience. I got pretty drunk and accidentally knocked over my bar stool when I got up to use the restroom. Apparently I was cut off? I don't even remember. I know at the time that this seemed like a pretty low level to sink to—knocking over my bar stool and getting cut off!—but who was I to know what lower depths I could truly plumb during my years at McNally's.
26. Nachos — For real, fuck the McNally's DJ. Awful music, including the most-played song, the worst song of all time, and the unofficial McNally's theme song: "Wobble" by V.I.C.
25. Tavern Pizza with Pepperoni — why buy pizza when Steve T. is gonna get off his shift at Vince's and bring all his leftover pizza to the bar at like 11 PM?
24. Onion Ring Burger — I had a theory growing up that, whenever I drank
and also ate anything with onions, I was guaranteed to throw up. So I
never had the onion ring burger, solely due to this biological myth.
Heard it was good, though.
23. Chicken Salad Wrap — I actually don't remember if I ever threw up at McNally's, despite my claim above. My mind is going back to a few hazy memories, but I don't think it ever happened inside McNally's. I think I knew it was coming and would usually walk out back. Though, like I said, I don't have any clear memories of such a thing happening, I'm just assuming based on how often I threw up in general. Maybe the aforementioned night of my 21st? Is that why I knocked down the bar stool?
22. Bacon BBQ Cheese Burger — Tough to not mention the Pike Hike as it relates to McNally's. I've already written about the erstwhile Northeast Philly tradition, and true to my word in 2017, I have not organized a Pike Hike since. But when it did occur annually, the final bar every year was McNally's. It made sense geographically and ideologically. The ongoing joke was "I had a good Pike Hike, but I don't even remember being at McNally's."
21. Cheeseburger — I remember bits and pieces of Pike Hike conclusions, but the moment that sticks out was when we were all having a GREAT time drinking and dancing, and I got caught up in the moment and tore my shirt off. The DJ—yes, the very same—stops the music and says "I'm not turning the music back on until your put your shirt on." Total fucking buzzkill. One more time, for the seats in the back: FUCK THE MCNALLY'S DJ!!!
20. Grilled Chicken & Bacon Sandwich — I don't know if I thought about this at all at the time (at least not right away), but McNally's definitely had some racist policies enacted when I first started going there. There were rules against hats, do-rags, boots, which were basically making assumptions that McNally's would have a reason to not allow a black person to enter. Bars in the Northeast are unfortunately still pretty segregated to this day. This isn't the only aspect of the Northeast I'm reckoning with as I grow older, but it's definitely one of the more prominent ones.
19. Hot Sausage Sandwich — McNally's was known for closing unreasonably early. Legally, they had to close at 2 AM of course, but so for McNally's, that meant last call at like 1:10 AM, and lights on at 1:25 AM, which seemed ridiculous to us (especially to those of us who could regularly make it till 1:10, and clearly still wanted to keep drinking).
18. Chicken Caesar Wrap — Though, as much as we would talk about it, we NEVER bought six-packs-to-go at last call to "continue the night" or whatever. We drank a lot and had a ton of stamina (relative to now, at least), but never that much.
17. Maynard Burger — As previously mentioned, McNally's had a shuffleboard table. We'd play every once in a while. I wasn't good, but I wasn't bad either. McNally's also had one of those virtual deer hunter games, as well as a bubble hockey game, and one of those touchscreen games at the end of the bar, none of which I ever played in all my years frequenting the joint. I feel like the deer hunter video game especially ended up being a coat rack most Friday nights.
16. Cheesesteak — Confirmed: McNally's cheesesteaks were never, not fucking once, named the Best Cheesesteak according to Philadelphia Magazine. For shame.
15. Chicken Cheesesteak — Pam did not like McNally's, I know that for sure. I still made her go with me more times than not, and to her credit, she never complained that much. (We did have an ongoing joke via text, after a typo in which I referred to the bar as "McAnally's," that we'd only call the bar McAnally's going forward.)
14. Buffalo Chicken Wrap — I've never had anal at McNally's, by the way.
13. Munchie Sampler — I remember that Thanksgiving Eve was so important to us that I literally begged my supervisor at my new job in 2013 to let me out early, and then had a coworker drive me directly to the bar, where I was quick to catch up. Craziest night of the year, usually (until two nights later, anyway).
12. Chicken Salad Club — Was I ever at McNally's sober? It was probably just that final Pike Hike, where I didn't drink at any of the bars, and each one got increasingly more uncomfortable. I probably lasted fifteen minutes before leaving.
11. French Fries —I remember the last time I was at McNally's. I didn't know it at the time, but it definitely did end up being the final sojourn. Pam was pregnant. I think the Usual Crowd got dinner at Hop Angel, and then walked across the street to enter that old haunt. I think everyone was pretty much over it at that point. I remember half the group sincerely thinking that the idea was a joke when we discussed our plans over dinner. Was I sober then too? I don't remember. Most likely I was just taking it easy, having recently started drinking again. Either way, it was a wet fart anticlimax of a night to go out on. Though I wonder how different it could've possibly been, even if we did know it was the last night we'd all be at McNally's together. Maybe we were too old by that point anyway.
10. Meatball Parmigiana — My favorite McNally's story occurred after Pam's and my "going away party" at McNally's, before we moved to Vegas, so this was February 2012. My parents were there, and they were sober enough that they drove a couple of cars back to their house with me and Pam and some friends. My dad drove my old '91 Camry. It's snowing at this point. Pam's in the passenger seat. Me and Dwyer and Dranders are in back seat. We're ready to pull out, and all of a sudden, some kid around our age is at the door, opening it, slurring something about getting a ride home. We didn't know this guy. My dad assumed that it was one of our friends. But he's trying to get in the car with us! So Dwyer says "My aunt is sick at the hospital, we have to go!" and my dad hits the gas as we shoot out of the lot. We look back, and the kid had slipped in the snow, and was on his back like a turtle as we turned onto Rhawn.
9. French Dip — Dwyer used to claim that McNally's was his favorite bar. This is the equivalent of the theory that the albums you listen to when you're seventeen are always going to be your favorite.
8. Cheese Fries — I don't necessarily think that it was my favorite bar of all time at any point in my life. There were only five months in between turning 21—when such an opinion as "favorite bar" would even be appropriate—and meeting Pam—who opened me up to all the bars in the rest of Philadelphia—so I don't think that's enough time to form any type of opinion about "favorites" one way or the other. Most frequented? At a certain point in my life, most definitely.
7. Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak — Like, I used to literally leave my parents' house and walk down to the bar in my slippers. That's the kind of bar McNally's was.
6. Grilled Chicken Patty — There were probably plenty of people who had the weirdest night of their lives there. I'm confident that I did. I did not have the worst night of my life there, but I know a couple friends for whom that is true. But how about best night? Could anyone possibly have the best night of their lives at McNally's? I kind of doubt it.
5. BLT — One time, me and Pam went with my parents to opening day at the Phillies. Me and my dad were waiting for the girls outside of the restrooms when all of a sudden, a short, stout, very drunken man came up and gave me a hug. We exchanged pleasantries, and then he stumbled off into the crowd. "Who was that?!" asked my dad. "Oh, that was Iggy, the cook at McNally's." This is really what McNally's was about, right? Or maybe all neighborhood bars are like this, and McNally's is no exception. There's a sense of community. I'm not claiming I was an intimate part of that community—I was a weekender, and if I was anything more than that, I might be in AA already—but at least I was there enough that I could pretend to be. I was comfortable enough there to consider the goddamn grill cook my friend.
4. Pork Roll Sandwich — (Iggy, through his connection with Kev, was with us when we traveled from La Salle to Camden for the Red Bull Flugtag. Picture it: Me, Kev, the middle-aged cook from McNally's, and about eighteen sophomore college girls.)
3. Tiniz — I felt comfortable there. Yeah, I make fun of McNally's often, and piss on its memory, even today. But I was always comfortable there, and knew I was gonna have a good time there (unless, of course, I was sober, which is a whole different story).
2. Wings — The nights are starting to bleed together in my mind. That's what happens when a neighborhood bar isn't conducive to much more than hunkering down with your friends and drinking pint after pint. It all starts to combine into one grand night at one single bar, getting tipsy, dancing on the tiny dance floor to the worst songs of all time, bullshitting with your best friends and many acquaintances, nothing truly "crazy" happening. Just good, clean, young fun. Well okay, maybe not good, and definitely not clean, but young for sure. When I was young, I drank at McNally's.
1. Tavern Pizza — Don't let anyone tell you any differently—McNally's had good pizza.
Happy Thanksgiving Eve, everybody. In another universe, somewhere really far away, we're all getting ready to post up at McNally's at 6 PM, and watching as every friend and every hoodrat we've ever drank with starts walking through the door. Cue the music!!!!!

No comments:
Post a Comment