Wednesday, November 3, 2021

Review: Only Murders in the Building


Watching this Hulu series has confirmed for me two things. One, I truly despise true crime serials. Two, I despise them because real life is never as interesting as fiction, and so a fictional take on the genre really has a chance to soar, when done right. Only Murders in the Building is an utterly delightful send-up of the genre, that also stays true to its confines and tropes. It works because it's not actually a true crime serial. It's a fake crime serial, and those are much better.

Like American Vandal, it's a hilarious parody of the whole phenomenon. Unlike American Vandal, some of the humor of OMitB is mined from being meta about the whole exercise, which I fucking loved. I'm attempting to write a spoiler-free review here, so I can't go into specifics, but I'll say that most of the twists tighten the mystery instead of make it more sprawling, and many of those twists have something to say about the whole true crime cottage industry.

But OMitB is also an actual murder mystery, so you get those old-timey whodunit thrills in the package as well. In a short amount of time, you grow to care about the central mystery, and genuinely look forward to resolving all those numerous cliffhangers. Binge this shit.
 
I've always thought Martin Short was hilarious, and he kills it in a somewhat comedic-relief role. I've always thought Steve Martin was a little overrated as an actor, but his character trends toward the straight-man role (save for the requisite slapstick physical comedy), and the performance ends up being net-neutral at worst. I've never thought anything about Selena Gomez before, but she really, really impresses here. The rest of the cast is filled with people who I'm told are Broadway theater stars, but greater minds will recognize more of them than me. Also, there's Amy Ryan.

I really don't know what else I can write, because I really don't want to spoil how it goes down, and that's most of the fun. I will say this: I am a man who hates podcasts in almost all forms, and so to watch a TV show that features characters who love podcasts and decide to create their own, and then still love that TV show? That's fucking impressive.
 
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: