Here is your instruction book. This is where you begin the review1. Here is where you tell the reader what you know about the band2, so that the reader can compare their own experiences to yours3. This is the point where you say what you know just from listening to the current album4. If you like it a lot, then you should temper expectations5. If you didn't like it that much, then you should name some exceptions6, some nice moments7, some things to take home with you8. If you thought it was okay9, you could always just do a paragraph in which you juxtapose some of the better songs with some of the worse songs10. Regardless, at this point you should underline your main point11. You can possibly make an inane comparison to some non-music thing12. This is the point where the reader is distracted and you can drop a reference to an old Record Club album13, for the true heads. Make sure you give an "explanation" as to why this review may not have been the best review you've ever written14. Equivocate further and say that this album was good enough to listen to throughout the week for whatever reason15. Drop a grade16. Edit this shit, make sure there are know typos17. Hit publish. Forget about the album for at least like three weeks.
1. On Thursday afternoon? Oof.
2. I dunno, probably as the Malcolm in the Middle band? Honestly, the whole side quest thing into children's music totally tracks for this band.
3. I could totally see how knowing a single fucking thing about They Might Be Giants might have enhanced your experience, so take mine with a grain of salt. That's how it goes with legacy bands who are new to yours truly within the context of Record Club.
4. So they definitely aren't a "parody" band by any stretch of the definition, but something about their whole shtick makes them reek of the genre anyway. I know from my experience this week only that they are a band who don't take themselves too seriously, and who have found a niche (and who have succeeded in that niche).
5. I would say something like "This is a rocking band who occasionally lapses into corny children-music-adjacent tunes, something silly like 'If Day for Winnipeg'" or whatever.
6. I would say something like "This album doesn't land too often, but those songs that do hit—the goofy guitar stomper 'Part of You Wants to Believe Me' or the even sillier but still fun 'Brontosaurus'—hit fucking hard" or something along those lines.
7. The four-on-the-floor "I Can't Remember the Dream."
8. The quirky stop-start waltz of "Wait Actually Yeah No," and so on.
9. This is the most accurate version of my opinion.
10. "...then you take the brutal urgency of album closer 'Less Than One' with some of the boring dreck like 'Quit the Circus'..." or maybe "...then you take the confidently theater-geeky 'Darling, the Dose' with some of the overly-geeky 'Drown the Clown'..." and there are like endless permutations of this game.
11. The vocals make this sound incredibly amateurish, despite the fact that those vocals are laid over music that is competent and catchy most of the time, and that amateurishness makes it really hard to take BOOK seriously.
12. E.g. it's like when someone says "fuck, man, the boneless skinless chicken breast from Aldi is always so tough," and later you're baked some chicken breast and it does seem a little chewy but you doubt you'd even have noticed if it wasn't for that one thing that was said up front, like, you don't know if this is a reflection of the chicken itself or your inability to block out opinions that can't possibly be based in fact.
13. Oh god, the vocals totally reminded me of Harry and the Potters. Yes, I overrated these guys at the time, but I still really like Lumos, and at this point, I have to acknowledge the fact that my love for the source material totally wallpapered over the fact that those guys sucked ass at singing too, ya know?
14. Yup, real shitty review. We are entering the final three weeks of the semester and I am getting my ass kicked. All apologies to everyone who has to sit there while I pretend that the half-assed footnotes premise was able to excuse any of the last-minute hack job.
15. I didn't mind this album. Liked it more than I disliked it, honestly.
16. GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
17. [sic]

No comments:
Post a Comment