Friday, August 6, 2021

Before These Crowded Streets, Joe


Anyone who defends Dave Matthews Band deserves to get their ass beat, and I will make sure of it in this review. Anyone who refers to Dave Matthews as "Dave" can feel free to step up to the plate right now and take a motherfucking swing.

Friend of Dave #1: "The best part about Dave Matthews Band is that it combines so many different disparate genres and sounds and stylings that it, in effect, refuses to be boxed in. There are no limits with Dave. There's rock, there's jazz, there's world music, there's bluegrass, there's pop. Their melting pot existence means that you really, truly do not know what you're going to get when you dig into a Dave album, and that's exciting, man."

I corner him, pull the tighty-whities out of his salmon-colored shorts, and hang him from underwear on a hook in the bathroom.

Friend of Dave #2: "DMB is one of those bands that you need to see live. It's incredible. Like the best jam bands, there's a thrill to the proceedings, that this music could go anywhere, ya know? That's why it's interesting to consider the DMB studio albums, like Before These Crowded Streets. Does it lose some of its magic when committed to tape? I'd argue not. In fact, I'd say that the 70-plus-minute runtime is justified for this reason. There is just so much factoring into the magic of Dave that it must've been hard to cut anything. To me, the album sounds like it's fifteen minutes, just like any three-hour Dave concert feels like thirty minutes tops. When you're having fun, you want more and more. Just let it all wash over you.

He gets an uppercut to the jaw, and while he's lying on the ground, I'm standing over him yelling "Bitch you coulda cut two minutes off every single one of these tracks!"

Friend of Dave #3: "I think that Before These Crowded Streets does a really good job of showing a different side of Dave Matthews as a vocalist. Dave dilettantes might only know his bright and smiling and a bit soulful and only slightly shopworn vocals from their radio hits, but on a couple tracks on this album, he... well, there's no other way to put it: he growls. It's kind of badass. You think of this guy as the genial leader of the board-shorted cult of Dave, and here he is flashing a dark side. It's scary in the way that the best horror films are scary. Speaking of, it's probably not a coincidence that one of the songs he does it on is called 'Halloween.'"

I grab him by the lapels and hang him over the railing on the third floor—"How's this for scary?!"—and he's whimpering and mewing the whole time like a scared little kitty cat.

Friend of Dave #4: "I've always been enthralled with Carter Beauford's drumming. There's a cliché about good drummers sounding like they have four arms, but Beauford is one of the few that I'm literally looking up pictures of him online just to confirm a normal anatomy. He is ambidextrous and plays open-handed (which means he doesn't cross his arms), so every rhythm on every songs starts to feel like a continuous drum fill. Watching him play this way makes me think he's about to give me a big hug. The snare hits are enormous (and come often). He plays a custom-made Yamaha Signature 'Beauford' Snare Drum, a prototype, i.e. not in production. With the amount of ghost notes this man fits into each measure, I can't imagine there is another snare drum in America that is being hit with a stick more often than his."

BANG, a right hand to the gut. "Jesus christ, even I am not this big of a drum nerd." POP, a left fist to the ribs. "You gotta know by now that no one likes hearing about drumming in music criticism. The only people who even notice drumming in music are former drummers!" BOOM, a vicious right on the temple. "Though I will say that it makes me VERY VERY ANGRY that Beauford was ranked #10 on RS's Best Drummers All-Time, and motherfucking Charlie Asshole Watts was at #9." CRASH, he hits the floor.

Friend of Dave #5: "At the very least, it's like a little time capsule of the late '90s, right? When else in music history could a weird adult contemporary amalgam of jazz and rock sell over four million copies? And be this popular? And fuel what is legitimately a cult? And be popular enough that the queen of the '90s herself is featured on two of your songs? It's worthy of respect for this alone."

This dude deserved the beatdown he got, because I watched the documentary about Woodstock '99, and all Dave Matthews could talk about was the number of "titties" he saw in the crowd. Pfff, the late '90s indeed.

Friend of Dave #6: "The power of their two radio hits from this album—'Stay (Wasting Time)' and especially 'Crush'—is undeniable, even all these years later. Even if you dismiss the deep cuts—which would be insane to do so, because these things are dense and rewarding and almost require dozens of listens to soak in—then you still have these two songs. Who among us wasn't moved by the majesty of 'Crush' as we cruised along in our parents' minivans way back when?"

Fists reign down upon him, one for every Crazy Bone I bought at Zany Brainy, because I heard "Crush" on the ride there every single time. It's too obvious of a point. Take this beatdown as a reminder.

But we're not finished.

Because now these same Dave fans, and literally millions more, all arise in unison. They surround me. Intentions of revenge are implied. I am scared.

I try to say: "But don't you get it?! Every album review is a portrait of the reviewer, not the album itself! I have literally typed all these nice words about Before These Crowded Streets because I believe them to be true! The ass-beatings I handed you were really a weird form of self-deprecation! It was all a bit! I swear!"

They don't care, and I am pummeled mercilessly. 

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

1 comment:

Joe K said...

I wrote the Charlie Watts crack before I knew he was sick. I hate his fucking guts and he is a noxiously awful drummer BUT I wish him a full recovery. https://www.stereogum.com/2156340/charlie-watts-likely-sitting-out-the-rolling-stones-us-tour/news/