Wednesday, May 29, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 67: Zach

Prompt: "Your favorite song from your least favorite genre"

Selected by Zach


"Will I?"
Steve and Company
RENT (Original Broadway Cast Recording), 1996

I've written about my disdain for musicals in this space before, but this song gets me every time. RENT is so ham-handed and makes me want to roll my eyes a bit, but you can't argue with how the music can sometimes hit you right in the feels. 

Still, musicals are my least favorite—I can't get into the baked-in cheesiness that seems to be part and parcel of the genre. Take the very lyrics to this song. "Will I lose my dignity... will someone care? Will I wake tomorrow, from this nightmare?" These lyrics aren't good. Musicals want to tell you a story to your face, without making you work hard for it. I prefer a David Lynch storytelling style, or a movie like Donnie Darko, pieces of pop culture that you might have go over a few times before you understand what they're trying to tell you. If I watch RENT once—hell, if I watch any musical once—I more than get the point it's trying to make. It's been shoved down my throat more times than I can count. 

And, yet, I love this song. Seeing the Charli XCX posts about the song from The Fault in Our Stars from a few days ago sent me down a rabbit hole of YouTube clips about the movie, and about romance, love, cancer, dying. Of course, RENT is about a newer and different disease (even if you've never seen RENT, you know this from South Park), but it hits the same notes. I have no idea why it's so fun for me to cry about a tragic love story, or someone who dies at the end of a movie, or to get emotional about anything, really, at all. But it is, and this song does it for me, all in a neat package. I'll listen to it repeat as it repeats itself.

1 comment:

Sara said...

"a newer, different disease" made me giggle