Prompt: "A song that passes the Bechdel Test"
Selected by Joe
"Hallelujah"
Haim
Women in Music Pt. III, 2020
Attempt 1
Woman 1: Okay, we're going to attempt to have a conversation that passes the Bechdel Test.
Woman 2: Who is writing this?
Woman 1: Joe.
Woman 2: No!! You're not supposed to talk about a man!!
Attempt 2
Woman 1: Trying again. This is our conversation. No breaking the fourth wall this time. We are two women, having a conversation.
Woman 2: I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that the women also need to be named in order for it to pass the test.
Woman 1: Fuck!!
Attempt 3
Chelsea: Okay, my name is Chelsea now.
Amelia: And my name is Amelia.
Chelsea: We were given these names by our mothers, who are female.
Amelia: We are going to talk about our mothers now. Not because they are female, but because this is what we talk about. Two women, chatting it up about other women.
Chelsea: Okay, but what about our mothers? What specifically are we talking about?
Amelia: We can talk about where each of them live.
Amelia: We can talk about where each of them live.
Chelsea: Okay, my parents live in—
Amelia: No! Don't mention your dad! Or even imply him! He is a man!
Attempt 4
Chelsea: It's easier for a movie to pass the Bechdel Test than it is for a song, because a movie just needs to include one scene out of many that follow its rules.
Amelia: Whereas a song would need to follow the rules the whole time, unless there are different scenes within the song, I guess?
Chelsea: I don't know, sounds like a pretty shitty prompt.
Amelia: Now here's a question. You're not outright mentioning a man, but you're alluding to one by mentioning the shitty prompt. Since the prompt was written by a man. Does that count as breaking the rule?
Chelsea: I think so. We should be strict here.
Attempt 5
Amelia: Okay, but how hard can this be? To have a conversation about ANYTHING besides a man?
Chelsea: You did it again.
Attempt 6
Chelsea: That's it. We're having a Bechdel Test conversation, starting... now. Let's go.
Amelia: Okay... um... what kind of, um... what is your favorite kind of cheese?
Chelsea: That's easy. Manchego.
Amelia: You can't be serious.
Chelsea: I am, why?
Amelia: The word "man" is right there. You couldn't have named literally any other cheese?
Chelsea: We would have been fine if you didn't have to point out the coincidence! This one is not my fault!
Attempt 7
Amelia: I guess we can't talk about romance.
Chelsea: We can if we are lesbians.
Amelia: That's true. Okay. I am a lesbian.
Chelsea: So am I.
Amelia: And I love you.
Chelsea: I love you too.
Amelia: You are all I ever need to talk about.
Chelsea: Same for me, regarding you. I could talk about my paramour Amelia all day. And cheese.
Amelia: We enjoy many of the same arts and entertainment.
Chelsea: Our favorite musical group is Sister Sledge.
Amelia: Our favorite movie is Mona Lisa Smile.
Chelsea: Which passes the Bechdel Test, according to a website that Joe just saw.
Amelia: You CANNOT BREAK THE FOURTH WALL, we've already been over this!!
Chelsea: But Joe is such a bad fucking writer for women, this is how it always is. He's always gotta, like, insert himself, even when it's just two women talking.
Amelia: Very annoying.
Chelsea: Very, very annoying.
Attempt 8
Amelia: Good morning, monogamous girlfriend at this completely secluded island that we've been on, just the two of us, for over a decade now, ever since the plane we were on during a class trip from our all-girls high school crash landed here and we were the only two survivors, how did you sleep?
Chelsea: I slept very well, thank you. And you?
Amelia: Just peachy. Did you catch the WNBA game last night?
Chelsea: I did. I am glad that we receive telecasts from this all-women's sports league on this remote island, though it's a shame that's the only TV program we get. I wish we would get, say, episodes of The Golden Girls, though I'd really only prefer to watch episodes that only feature the four main characters, all of them women.
Amelia: Despite that, it really does feel like we have everything we need.
Chelsea: With you here, it feels like I have everyone I need.
Amelia: Amen to that.
Chelsea: I thank god every day that we ended up here together.
Amelia: And of course, it need not be said, but I'll say it anyway—I'm glad that we both believe that god is a woman. A great bearded woman who lives in the clouds.
Chelsea: Yup, makes sense to me.
Amelia: This is starting to feel a little like mocking.
Chelsea: Right? I thought the Bechdel Test was supposed to help determine how well a particular piece of work represents women?
Alison Bechdel: That's not necessarily true.
Amelia: Wow, famed cartoonist Alison Bechdel, architect of the Bechdel Test!
Chelsea: Thanks for visiting our island to help explain the test you came up with! It is convenient that you are here, and helpful that you are a woman!
Alison Bechdel: The Test is more designed to call attention to gender inequality in fiction. Think about it. You could write a fifty-page scene in which two women are stuck on a deserted island with nothing but WBNA broadcasts on the television, which doesn't even make sense logically, and, I don't know, sounds like some kind of cheap sexist joke, right? Or maybe there's a three-hour movie, and four minutes of that movie are two women talking about cheese, but the other two hours and 56 minutes consist of four male frat boys making unwanted sexual advances on coeds who don't even have any lines of dialogue for themselves. The Bechdel Test means nothing if you're going by technicalities.
Amelia: You just mention men.
Alison Bechdel: See what I mean?
Attempt 9
Chelsea: Okay, so the Haim song "Hallelujah."
Amelia: Which is NOT a cover of the Rufus Wainwright Shrek song.
Chelsea: I understand why you had to do that, but it doesn't make it any less frustrating.
Attempt 10
Chelsea: Okay, so the Haim song "Hallelujah."
Amelia: Not related to any other song coincidentally named that.
Chelsea: Thank you. Written by three sisters.
Amelia: And it is about those three sisters.
Chelsea: And the love they share for one another.
Amelia: Female sisters.
Chelsea: And each sister takes a verse, as if they are speaking with one another.
Amelia: About each other, and no one else.
Chelsea: Well technically, Alana's verse is about a friend who passed away at age 20 in a car accident.
Amelia: The friend was female.
Chelsea: Not that it would've made the song any less powerful if that friend was of any other gender, but I'm just saying, we're strict on the Bechdel Test here, still.
Amelia: We are specifically not mentioning anyone who may have produced the song or directed the music video.
Chelsea: The existence of other humans doesn't negate the bona fides of the Bechdel Test. The point is the subjects of conversation. So if we don't mention Rostam or Ariel Rechtshaid or Paul Thomas Anderson, then that's not because they weren't important to the creation of this good song, but more so because they aren't necessary to the point we are trying to make in this conversation. The point isn't that it's a good song for such and such a reason. The fact that it's good and the reasons that it's good can all remain unstated. We're trying to talk about the important emotions elicited in this song's lyrics, which are about three female sisters and the bond they share.
Amelia: You just named three men in that paragraph, which is fine, I get why you did it, but unfortunately, we still haven't passed the test.
Chelsea: Okay, c'mon, let's do this. I'm done after this one whether we pass or fail.
Final Attempt
Chelsea: Tell me about the plot of Mona Lisa Smile.
Amelia: Julia Roberts gets hired at Wellesley College and teaches young women about modern art.
Chelsea: Sounds like a good one. Julia Roberts is a great actress. I wonder what her favorite cheese is?
Amelia: According to this article written by a woman, it might be feta?
Chelsea: And Este Haim likes mozzarella, despite her IBS. I love the Haim sisters.
Amelia: This is a great song.
Chelsea: Cheese is amazing.
Amelia: This blog post fucking rocks.
Chelsea: Right? Just the best. I'm sure whoever wrote is probably a woman. She is doing a great job. She is writing fictional women so well. Good work, ma'am. Good work.
Amelia: All our problems have been solved. Thanks, Bechdel Test.
Alison Bechdel: This is starting to sound like mockery again. I vote that it's worth fucking up the Test if it means we get to talk shit about the author. All in favor, say "aye"?
Chelsea: Aye.
Amelia: Aye.
Alison Bechdel: Then it's settled. FUCK YOU, JOE K***!!!!!!!!
1 comment:
i liked this a lot
Post a Comment