Thursday, February 15, 2018

The Albums That Matter: Aldhils Aboretum

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Aldhils Arboretum
Of Montreal
2002

Aldhils Arboretum is Of Montreal's fifth out of thirteen (very soon fourteen) albums. Kevin Barnes' project is so far removed from where it began at this point that listening to an album like Aldhils Arboretum is like looking at pictures you're tagged in on Facebook from high school. That's what I looked like?!

Of Montreal has always been extremely hit or miss for me. I'm sure I'll expound on it at least once at some point in the next thirteen album write-ups. Honestly, it was one of those things where I had three of their albums, and I liked them so much that I went and downloaded the other nine, and it was just disappointment after disappointment.

Aldhils Arboretum is definitely a disappointment, there's no doubt about it. But today was honestly the first time I've listened to the thing in a couple years, and I was surprised about how much more I liked it than I remembered. Still not great. But very listenable!

On this album, Barnes continually strikes me as someone who can write a really good short story, but also someone who has not quite mastered how to write a successful hook as well. Seriously, listening to some of these songs makes me feel like someone is singing The New Yorker to me.

Take, like, "The Blank Husband Epidemic." I really like this story about a guy that ultimately choose infidelity over suicide. It's bleak and a little funny around the edges. But musically, there's really nothing here. Absolutely nothing that grabs you, nothing that you find yourself humming along to later in the day.

I'm trying to articulate a very specific problem, bear with me: Barnes does this thing over and over on the album. It's like, sometimes he's trying to fit in more lyrics than can fit on a line, but there isn't enough music to match up with the lyrics, so the music sounds like a broken record in the background. It happens on "We Are Destroying the Song," on "Question for Emily Foreman," etc. It doesn't ruin the album, it's just a minor annoyance.

And of course, there is always an exception, and here, "Jennifer Louise" is the song. It's pretty much perfect. It gets everything right that Of Montreal typically gets wrong. It's clear and concise, the hook is right out front, it doesn't fuck around. If the band was to release a Greatest Hits album, this is the only song from Aldhils Arboretum that would come close to making the cut.

I feel like this is a forgotten album in Of Montreal's discography. It doesn't really fit in during any of their "periods." It's not a twee rock opera. It's not lo-fi. The titles of the songs are short and filled with common words. It's not from the demented mind of a crossing-dressing alter ego. Compared to the rest of Of Montreal's albums, this one is tame as fuck. And yeah, a little forgettable.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Old People in the Cemetery"



~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Okay, so after listening to this album and writing this up, I'm actually excited to get into the rest of Of Montreal's LPs for this project. Some of their albums I consider straight up terrible, but if Aldhils can go from "not that good" to "pretty good" in my mind, then maybe I can actually find things I like about, say, The Bedside Drama.
  • Man, this really IS a forgettable album though, isn't it? I went through five or six pages of google searches and didn't really find anything pertinent to this album, the context behind it, or anything. I guess because 2002 was prior to the online music journalism boom, but the album is too insignificant to merit any nostalgic pieces?
  • Stereogum, of course, included the album when they ranked Of Montreal Worst to Best. #10 out of twelve ain't bad I guess.
  • FRONT COVER: Two figures spooning, one all white, and one multicolored. Kevin Barnes' brother David Barnes is the band's official art director, and has drawn most of the record covers as far as I can tell. Per his wiki: "The covers typically have unique color schemes and illustrations achieved through a combination of thick watercolors, markers, and ink." Aldhil's cover seems way more sparse than some of the other wacko shit he comes up with in a few years.
  • I see the band's name stylized a lot as "of Montreal" but I refuse to do that shit. The O is going to be capitalized here and in all future mentions of Of Montreal.

NEXT TIME: Algiers by Algiers

No comments: