Wednesday, February 7, 2018

The Albums That Matter: Against Me! as the Eternal Cowboy

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Against Me! as the Eternal Cowboy
Against Me!
2003

The hindsight of knowing Laura Jane Grace's story make for a fascinating experience listening to Against Me!'s older albums. In 2014, I described Grace as "brave," and I still believe that. I can only imagine how much courage one would need to come out as Trans. I salute her.

If Against Me! was brave in 2014, then what to make of Against Me! in 2003? Where was the band at this point? What was their purpose?

At the turn of the century, Against Me! was an anarchist punk band, a conceit that was exciting at the time, especially for like-minded "anarchists," but now, the whole thing seems a little half-baked. A couple reasons this might be the case.

First, it may be because the "authority" that Grace / the band is rebelling against has changed so much since 2003. "Sink, Florida, Sink" appeared on a compilation called Rock Against Bush, Vol. 1. Here in 2018, the evils of Bush-era politics seem minuscule compared to the horror show of trumpian fascism. Some of the lyrics still hold true, like "Rice and Bread"'s "Can you imagine if we started demanding?" speaking to the importance of making your plea for justice known. Other shit just seems like anarchy-by-numbers at this point (see: all of "Mutiny on the Electronic Bay").

And so, second, it may just be on me for thinking this is all cliché. They literally comment on this in "Cliché Guevara," a song that promises that Against Me! is NOT like all those bands that just use anarchist symbols as a way to sell pop records. But at the end of the day, it seems to me that they ARE just like those bands? Like, what differentiates "Turn Those Clapping Hands into Angry Balled Fists" from every other anthem about the crushing normality of life?

All that said, the music itself is impeccable, as are the vocals, as always. Fucking badass, honestly. And even the lyrics are a home run during those moments when the anarchy shtick is put aside for more personal revelations (fuck, "You Look like I Need a Drink" cuts me deep every time). No one will ever accuse Against Me! of being a consistent band, unless the consistency is that they put out genuinely enjoyable albums time after time. It's just that the reasons for the enjoyment change every time.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Cliche Guevara"



~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • Grace has an origin story for her hatred of authority; basically, she was arrested as a teen, tried as an adult, and given felony charges, all because she was, according to her, hanging out on the boardwalk wearing punk rock clothing. That's it. Which to me sounds unfair, but at the end of the day, not enough to want to Tear Down the Establishment™. In many ways, Grace coming out as Trans retroactively justified her long history of saying FUCK THE MAN.
  • I guess Against Me! was originally going to have their band name at the front of every album title, as their first album, the one before this, is Against Me! Is Reinventing Axl Rose (the only Against Me! album I'm not familiar with, and so you will not be reading about it tomorrow). You would be reading this blog post in 2019 if they didn't do that.
  • FRONT COVER: A basic picture of a man in punk rock clothing. Per wiki, Grace at the time was doing a lot of "binging and purging," meaning she would be crossdressing for a while in private and then going through periods of swearing off all femininity. Choosing a picture of a clearly masculine figure for the cover may have been during a purging period, is my guess. I'm so fucking happy for her that she came out and was able to live the life she wants to live.
  • I just added this album to my iPod a few weeks ago. I'm really glad I did. I hope sometime this year I get around to completing the Against Me! discography and dive into their debut album. I need the whole picture. I apologize if the picture I painted above of the early days of the band is incomplete due to this hole in my musical knowledge of the band.

NEXT TIME: The Age of Adz by Sufjan Stevens

No comments: