Saturday, May 11, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 58: Joe

Prompt: "Your favorite Nickelback song"

Selected by Joe


"Where Do I Hide"
Nickelback
Silver Side Up, 2001

I think there is a way to be optimistic about this without being stupid.

Being stupid would be saying something like "actually..." and then follow those ellipses down the path that you can all guess. The "Nickelback is good" path. C'mon. Don't do that. It's not necessary here.

But there is room for optimism and for grace. I heard snippets of a World Café interview with the band a couple months ago. I don't know if this was a new episode or if it was a repeat (and, let's be real, it was kinda surprising World Café was featuring goddamn Nickelback to begin with). This was like March when they were playing it on the radio, and I don't remember the specifics, and I'm not going to go back and relisten to the whole thing and check any of the details, it ain't that important. But the general gist of the interview was that Nickelback was obviously aware of their reputation, and they seemed pretty level-headed about it. Which I thought was pretty endearing.

It doesn't matter the context—being told that you suck is gonna hurt you. Nickelback, for whatever reason, either is or was the band attached to the vitriol and blowback of butt rock. I don't know why. I don't know their music well enough to say that it's because of their music, but knowing what I know, I don't think that's it. At least not completely. They were popular, and they sold a lot of records, and I think that's the thing that gives someone like me—music critic, even though it's music critic by hobby—permission to say "this band sucks." Nickelback was so commercially successful that critical derision felt like punching up. A band with a similar sound but with twelve fans would be worthy of that derision on a musical level, but the criticism would feel like an act of punching down. And that feels bad. No one wants to punch down.

So through that World Café thing, I felt empathy, and I felt proud of these human beings for facing the brand of adversity they faced with much aplomb and geniality. But that's as far as it goes for me. Everyone was right when they said the music sucked, ya know? That wasn't the wrong part. Maybe the wrong part was getting personal with it. Jokes like "Osama Bin Laden chose September 11, 2001 as the date of the attack because he was trying to prevent anyone from listening to Silver Side Up, but he was a few hours late, Sam Goody was already open before the first plane hit" can be fun and funny but also are hyperbole by design, and it must've been pretty terrible to be the dudes who were making music they were passionate about and be faced with the laughter of most of the people on this planet who give a shit about music. Yes, yes, they were crying all the way to the bank, etc., I'm not talking about crass dollar signs here. I'm not even talking about art, which is completely separate from money, even though some people try to disagree with me on that point. No, I'm talking about basic human emotions. I'm saying that any fucking person, no matter what, is going to feel worse about themselves when they hear something said about them in a negative way. That's just how humans operate. And I'm saying that in this particular case, separate from the music, I sympathize with the members of Nickelback.

This is definitely something we've talked about before: we're seeing now a lot of the subpar music we heard in our generation's youth be reevaluated now that our peers are becoming the critics and art creators and gatekeepers. I wrote about this re: Matchbox Twenty, who saw a commercial and critical resurgence due to the Barbie thing. A couple decent hits, but nothing to write home about, and absolutely nothing that we can point to and say "actually, we were wrong about this band, they were really good!"

What I'm surmising now is that we will never need to talk about 20/Twenty Vision when it comes to Nickelback. In order for an artist's work to be critically reevaluated, there needs to be something that a younger critic can see that the older generation missed due to their age and proximity to the blast area. But with Nickelback, there's nothing there. All of us, everyone of every age, we can all agree that this music kinda stinks. No reevaluation is possible. No one could reevaluate this if they tried.

A true hero would run through Nickelback's discography for this prompt, just to make absolutely certain that that's true. I'm not the guy. This isn't like the Adele situation the other day; I didn't accidentally run into a good Nickelback song as I skimmed their 9/11 album. It was all pretty bad. I chose "Where Do I Hide" because it was the least worst of what I heard. That makes it my "favorite" by default. If I write anything else about this, I'll be at risk of ruining the joke as it is laid out by today's YSC prompt.

But just suffice it to say that Nickelback's music isn't good. We already knew this. Sometimes it's just easier to take the then-present-day critics at their word than imagine a world in which every band could stand to be critically reevaluated. Let's not do that. Let's just appreciate Nickelback for what they are: a group of ugly dudes who are doing what they love and making a lot of money for doing what they love and staying very grounded with the idea that the thing they are doing because they love doing it just happens to be a thing that a lot of people hate. I think there's room to be nice about it. I don't think there's room for musical enjoyment.

2 comments:

Joe K said...

Joe's Ranking of Nickelback Songs Today

8. "Photograph"
7. "Rockstar"
6. "San Quentin"
5. "Far Away"
4. "Where Do I Hide"
3. "Savin' Me"
2. "One Last Run"
1. "How You Remind Me"

Notes

— Avril's Nickelback cover does not count for the official rankings, but I'd argue that the choice was handled perfectly.

— "Photograph" is probably the worst song of all time, but it struck me today for the first time that this would've been an even more massive hit if it had been recorded as a country song.

— Extremely rough day of music, all in all. Thanks to everyone who bit the bullet and participated.

Pat said...

"Photograph" is much funnier if you imagine it's Joe singing about Rockledge.