Saturday, July 24, 2021

A Year of Blind Spots: The Shepherd's Dog


If The Shepherd's Dog is like a cop beating the shit out of me—Pam included "House by the Sea" on a mix CD she gave me years ago; Allison spoke highly of it right on this very blog; I have had good things to say about other Iron & Wine albums; The Shepherd's Dog has always been their most critically-acclaimed work; Pam is clearly familiar with it enough to be able to recall its song titles at will—then this was the week that it yelled "stop resisting!" and I went limp and took my nickel ride.

That is a sinister metaphor for what many would assume to be somewhat of a wimpy musical project. I can see it. Sam Beam's vocals have a soft, soulful quality to them that I can't even fucking imagine in my wildest dreams rising to a shout. If you're entry point to I&W was, like me, Our Endless Numbered Days, then maybe you're extrapolating. My experience this week tells me that that would be unfair. The Shepherd's Dog kicks ass.

Here's the problem with assuming that Beam's voice is too gentle: when the music heats up, it doesn't even fucking matter. It actually creates kind of a thrilling juxtaposition, is what I'm seeing on this album. Take something like "White Tooth Man." Beam still sounds pretty dreamy, but the tempo (faster), rhythm (bongos and crashing cymbals), and theme (small-town trouble) all create a sense of unease that's thrilling, perhaps even more so when paired with the vocals. Or like in "Boy with a Coin" (which, now that I'm thinking about it, has the same "Hey-ey-ey-ey" hook as "White Tooth Man"), when the clapping goes double time in the chorus. It's not like Beam is reaching new heights himself, it's just that the music around him is getting him there in a different way.

So yes, this is a week of "duh" in terms of whether I'd like this so-called "classic." I do. A lot. Duh. I promise to stop resisting.




No comments: