Over a year ago now, I compiled a list of 200 movies I had never seen but wanted to (or at least felt like I should), and I've spend the last year crossing them off the list, by watching them in alphabetical order. Extrapolating from here, I will be done this project by the Summer of 2024. I think it might be time to accelerate the process here.
Diary of a Mad Black Woman
2005
It took me a while to bring myself to write this entry in the Never Seen It series. It wasn't a matter of having to gather my thoughts, but more a matter of having too many thoughts, and not enough guideposts telling me which of those thoughts would be appropriate to share. I feel like, by giving myself a week before sitting down to write about it, I was able to allow time to smooth out my opinions, to dull any spiky thoughts I might've been tempted to share last week. So let's start here:
A month or two ago, I was waiting in line at the CVS, and happened to see the cover of a recent issue of Entertainment Weekly. The issue (or special booklet, or whatever) was all about Black Film, and the cover was adorned with famous black characters and actors/actresses in history. This was right after I had seen The Color Purple, and right before Coming to America (I was surprised that, out of those two, Whoopi was the one snubbed, though I guess Coming 2 America was on the editors' minds at the time of publication). There wasn't any kind of indication that these were the BEST characters in Black Film; I took it more as that these are recognizable faces. Because, of course, up there in the top right corner, it featured a picture of Madea.
That I am familiar with this character—who is played by creator and filmmaker Tyler Perry in a fat suit and drag—should show how thoroughly Perry's creation has saturated the entertainment world in the past two decades, because up until now, I had never seen a minute of any of the films. I chose Diary of a Mad Black Woman for my Never Seen It list because I wanted to change that, and it made sense to choose the first in the series, but let's note here that there are TEN SEQUELS in this franchise. You don't make eleven movies featuring the same character if no one is aware of its existence.
I'm not here to discuss why the character of Madea is famous, or infamous, or whatever. At least, not directly. The answer to the question is that there are so many Madea movies that it's kind of impossible not to know about her, right?
Also, to discuss it any further—like, any discussion of should this character be as famous as she is—might be stepping on the toes of another question. This subsequent question is the one that made me pause for an entire week without writing a single word about this film. The question is: Should I, a straight white male, even have the right to have any sort of opinion about it whatsoever? I've decided that the answer to that question is "no." I do not. I'm okay with that! I'm not, like, bitter that there are certain works of art that are not for me, to say nothing of their quality or lack thereof. To think otherwise, i.e. to think that everything on every screen could be meant for me, would betray a certain ignorance of my privilege as straight white male. That's something I'm trying to be more aware of.
But that rubs up against the ostensible purpose of this film column, and this blog in general. You're here to read my opinions and my stories. You are here because you want to hear what I have to say, whether you want to admit it or not. I'm not saying this in a haughty or bragging way, because I know I'm not necessarily good at doing this thing, even after 2000+ blog posts. But at the end of the day, there are a billion websites out there, and you could go to motherfucking anywhere to read about any goddamn movie I could possibly write about here. The one single thing I can bring to the table on Puke on Your Birthday is my own personal viewpoint. Without that, then there's no fucking reason to be here.
So now, I'm going to report other people's opinions about Diary of a Mad Black Woman and Madea as a concept, but I'm only doing so because without it, there'd be nothing left. I have nothing personal to bring to it, either because I can't or I won't or I shouldn't (and it doesn't matter which, ultimately). But I have to write something here, and so here it is.
Diary of a Mad Black Woman, and Madea, and Tyler Perry, are all pretty polarizing withing the black community. That much is clear from all the reading I did about this franchise after watching the movie. Some people believe that any film made for black people is a net positive, and there is no doubt that the Madea movies are financially successful and also definitely made by and for black people. Other people believe that Madea only serves to further harmful stereotypes, and is basically a modern-day minstrel show. I can see both sides, and again, I cannot have a stake in either side, I'm just reporting what others have said. (I also read that Spike Lee takes issue with the success of Tyler Perry, and I read that Perry basically told him to fuck off.)
Probably the most nuanced take I saw—if opinions on nuance are allowed—was one black film critic who took less offense at Madea as a character and more at Perry as a filmmaker. He said that he was proud that a black filmmaker was able to carve out such a lucrative space in the movie business, but that he felt that Perry wasn't doing enough to allow other black filmmakers into that space. He cited a video in which Perry showed his social media followers piles and piles of scripts that he had written, saying "I wrote all these myself!" But this critic points out that, if Perry is writing all these scripts himself, then imagine how many other black people he could've hired to help write those scripts.
Okay, I changed my mind. I'm going to give my opinion about this film, but let's keep the caveat: You and I are both fully aware that this opinion means absolutely nothing, because Diary of a Mad Black Woman was not made for someone like me. So when I say that Diary of a Mad Black Woman was an absolutely awful movie—and it was—you should take that with an unimaginably large grain of a salt.
I really only bring this up because I think it's interesting, and maybe you will too—my opinion about this movie is pretty much the opposite of Roger Ebert's, another straight white male, who died before he was forced to grapple with the idea that maybe he shouldn't be reviewing every single movie, due to his straightness, and whiteness, and maleness. Anyway, Ebert's review is basically this: there's a decent marital drama at the center of Diary of a Mad Black Woman, but Madea both literally and figuratively takes a chainsaw to that movie with her out-of-place violent slapstick comedy.
And I think this is completely backwards! I turned to Pam about an hour into our viewing of Diary and said "I can't believe I'm going to say this, but I wish Madea was in this movie more." Not because I was enthralled by Perry's performance (though there was exactly one line-reading as the Madea character that legitimately made me laugh, but I didn't write it down and now I forget it), but more so because the other bullshit around it felt like a Z-list soap opera. Ebert was correct in that Madea constantly interrupts the story, but unlike Ebert, I welcomed the interruption.
I actually think my problems with the A-plot—which is basically about a woman whose rich husband cheats on her and divorces her, and how she enacts her revenge—don't stem from my straightness, or whiteness, or maleness, but actually from my agnosticism. Diary of a Mad Black Woman, at least in every Madea-less scene, is overtly a Christian film, and man, there is just nothing about that kind of thing that could ever have any impact on me.
I'm realizing now that couching my criticism in the subject of religion is probably the most appropriate and least awkward way of crowbarring my opinions into this at all. Unlike race or gender, one can choose their religion. Choosing Christianity is not a choice I disdain or respect or whatever, but I can say that choosing to tell your story as a religious parable is a choice that I roll my eyes at.
It's important to note for two reasons, really. One is that the Christianity part of this filmmaker's franchise is the genesis of its success, if you think about it. Tyler Perry originally staged this story as a play, and churches were busing their members into the theater in droves. Without all the talk about God's love, there would be no money in it either. But then the second thing that's important is the irony that Madea is the thing that everyone takes away from this movie, and she is literally the farthest thing away from the movie's central Christian message. Everyone else is trying to make right in the eyes of God, and Madea's over here threatening to slap a ho, and getting ankle monitors placed on her, and so on.
Maybe that says more about me than it does the movie, that I'd rather watch Tyler Perry in drag pull a gun out of her purse than a nice Christian woman finding the strength to forgive those who've harmed her. Maybe that's me playing into the whole idea of this being a minstrel show! Maybe I'm contributing to the racist aspects of it by laughing at stereotypes! I don't know! Fuck me if it is! All I'm saying, really, is that there are two movies here, and both were pretty bad, but one was slightly better than the other, and the movie I think is better is different than but also kind of the same as what other people think, and also fuck me for even thinking I could have an opinion about any of it, especially if it's going to be an assbackwards take like "gun-totin' grandma GOOD, serious religious protagonist BAD."
I know, I know—this is another bad blog post, and another one in which I am hiding behind its incoherence as a defense mechanism. If this essay is poorly written and lacks a central thesis, well then, maybe you won't even realize that I have nothing constructive to add to the conversation! But if this essay really did have a central thesis, it'd probably be something like: Diary of a Mad Black Woman was bad, but who am I to say? Because it wasn't made for me! No, wait, here's a better central thesis: Fuck Joe K***. This is probably the one we can all get behind.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: It's not always easy to convince Pam to watch a movie with me, but it helps if it's something like Dirty Dancing, a movie that she has seen multiple times and already loves. Let's see if I end up feeling the same way.

No comments:
Post a Comment