Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.
Look, there's not much to dive into here; the pool is too shallow. I don't necessarily mean that as an insult. Sometimes rock music is just there to listen to, not to explore like a map or digest like a novel or study like an ancient scroll. As You Were is just there. It's fun in its simplicity and sameness. It doesn't scintillate, but burns a steady glow. It is basically Oasis-lite from the Oasis frontman. Almost exactly a year since As You Were was released, I still enjoy listening to it from time to time when I need something that is straightforward and uncomplicated. But where does that leave the blogger in me?
Let's consult my notes here. There were four potential leads we could've followed for the hook to this short essay, all of them pretty weak:
1. The disgraceful Kavanaugh debacle may have so successful gaslighted me, at least for the time being, that I can barely even bring myself to comment on another alleged abuse allegation. The dude was on tape as having choked his girlfriend. It's fucked up. But the whole point of the Me Too movement is to respect the victim and her voice in these matters. And according to the alleged victim, Debbie Gwyther, it is... "a pack of lies." Either she is being threatened to stay silent or there is more to this story. Let's Occam's razor this shit and move on for now.
2. The "As You Were" question is easy to answer with a little research. The title comes from the tweets, and the tweets come from... well, not even Liam Gallagher is sure. In a radio interview, he explains, "John Lennon used to wear these t-shirts with 'You are here,' and I always just liked that. It kind of reminds me of 'as you were.' I mean it doesn’t really mean anything, but you know, I think it looks good." So basically it's just a self-imposed catchphrase of sorts. Nothing to see here.
3. I can't answer this because I just wasn't interested in exploring the new Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds album at the time. It was late in the year, I was wrapping up the year's end reviews, and so I was choosing carefully the new stuff I still wanted to listen to. Who Built the Moon? was getting tepid-to-fine reviews, and the few singles I listened to didn't really do anything for me, so I forwent it. I have no stakes in the brotherly rivalry, and no interest in awarding either party as the so-called winner. For what it's worth, Noel's previous album, 2015's Chasing Yesterday, is pretty fucking great, and I would probably choose that album over As You Were. But who cares?
4. If there is a subject I'm less qualified to answer than the Gallagher rivalry, it's the history of the Britpop movement. All my knowledge of Britpop added up could probably fit into a single bottle of champagne supernova. Actually, me and Pam watched that CNN docuseries about the '90s the other night (the music episode, obviously), and they described Britpop as "the hangover after grunge," which to me sounds pretty reductive, but what the fuck do I know. If there's a time and place to do my own research, it'll be as soon as Be Here Now's PoYB essay, if I ever get around to listening to that. For now, let's assume that As You Were makes no great strides away from the classic Britpop sound.
Suffice it to say that this is a good album, but it's nothing to go crazy over. The album is certified Platinum in the UK though, so again, what the fuck do I know. As you were JK x.
As You Were
Liam Gallagher
2017
Look, there's not much to dive into here; the pool is too shallow. I don't necessarily mean that as an insult. Sometimes rock music is just there to listen to, not to explore like a map or digest like a novel or study like an ancient scroll. As You Were is just there. It's fun in its simplicity and sameness. It doesn't scintillate, but burns a steady glow. It is basically Oasis-lite from the Oasis frontman. Almost exactly a year since As You Were was released, I still enjoy listening to it from time to time when I need something that is straightforward and uncomplicated. But where does that leave the blogger in me?
Let's consult my notes here. There were four potential leads we could've followed for the hook to this short essay, all of them pretty weak:
- Liam Gallagher was very recently caught on video choking his girlfriend at a restaurant, and was being questioned by the police. Does this alleged incident add anything to our understanding of the album?
- The album is called As You Were, and Liam Gallagher typically ends each of his tweets with the phrase "as you were." Was the album named after his twitter signature, or does he tweet this because of the album title? Or do both uses of the phrase originate from some third source?
- Liam's brother and former Oasis bandmate Noel Gallagher released a solo album around the same time last year. Which one was better? Should we even be comparing the two?
- Having been part of Oasis and thus a leader in the mid-1990s Britpop movement, how does this album fit into the Britpop pantheon?
1. The disgraceful Kavanaugh debacle may have so successful gaslighted me, at least for the time being, that I can barely even bring myself to comment on another alleged abuse allegation. The dude was on tape as having choked his girlfriend. It's fucked up. But the whole point of the Me Too movement is to respect the victim and her voice in these matters. And according to the alleged victim, Debbie Gwyther, it is... "a pack of lies." Either she is being threatened to stay silent or there is more to this story. Let's Occam's razor this shit and move on for now.
2. The "As You Were" question is easy to answer with a little research. The title comes from the tweets, and the tweets come from... well, not even Liam Gallagher is sure. In a radio interview, he explains, "John Lennon used to wear these t-shirts with 'You are here,' and I always just liked that. It kind of reminds me of 'as you were.' I mean it doesn’t really mean anything, but you know, I think it looks good." So basically it's just a self-imposed catchphrase of sorts. Nothing to see here.
3. I can't answer this because I just wasn't interested in exploring the new Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds album at the time. It was late in the year, I was wrapping up the year's end reviews, and so I was choosing carefully the new stuff I still wanted to listen to. Who Built the Moon? was getting tepid-to-fine reviews, and the few singles I listened to didn't really do anything for me, so I forwent it. I have no stakes in the brotherly rivalry, and no interest in awarding either party as the so-called winner. For what it's worth, Noel's previous album, 2015's Chasing Yesterday, is pretty fucking great, and I would probably choose that album over As You Were. But who cares?
4. If there is a subject I'm less qualified to answer than the Gallagher rivalry, it's the history of the Britpop movement. All my knowledge of Britpop added up could probably fit into a single bottle of champagne supernova. Actually, me and Pam watched that CNN docuseries about the '90s the other night (the music episode, obviously), and they described Britpop as "the hangover after grunge," which to me sounds pretty reductive, but what the fuck do I know. If there's a time and place to do my own research, it'll be as soon as Be Here Now's PoYB essay, if I ever get around to listening to that. For now, let's assume that As You Were makes no great strides away from the classic Britpop sound.
Suffice it to say that this is a good album, but it's nothing to go crazy over. The album is certified Platinum in the UK though, so again, what the fuck do I know. As you were JK x.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Greedy Soul"
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Stray Observations
- Genius' annotations are absolutely filled to the brim with quotes from Gallagher regarding each song. Every quote pretty much amounts to the following: "Oh yeah, I love this song. It's a classic." I don't think it's a vanity thing, though...
- ...especially because Gallagher is pretty honest with his limited songwriting abilities, and his dependence on other songwriters (his brother prior to Oasis' break-up, producer Greg Kurstin and songwriter Andrew Wyatt on this album). So when I see him saying overly-nice things about his own songs, I see him complimenting his partners more so than patting himself on the back.
- Kurstin actually won a Grammy for his work on As You Were (among other albums), which probably gives you a hint as to how much help Liam Gallagher had here. Not that that's a bad thing, I'm just saying.
- Okay, so you know how I was saying that I didn't know jack shit about Britpop? Let the record show that I had no idea that Liam Gallagher was the frontman of Oasis until today. I thought it was Noel Gallagher. I don't know why I got their roles mixed up. I really need to do some more exploring into the mid-'90s rock scene.
- ALBUM COVER: It's a photo of Gallagher's face. He has a very punchable face. Maybe that was the point of putting it on the cover; Gallagher seems to do a lot of things that cause people to want to punch him in the face, and he seems to lean into that tendency by saying even more ridiculous nonsense.
NEXT TIME: Astral Weeks by Van Morrison

No comments:
Post a Comment