Tuesday, October 2, 2018

The Albums That Matter: Armchair Apocrypha

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Armchair Apocrypha
Andrew Bird
2007

Leave it to our favorite lyrics-second artist to title his album with a word I had to look up in the dictionary. "Apocrypha" is defined by Merriam-Webster as "writings or statements of dubious authenticity." When something is defined as "armchair," it typically signifies that it is amateurish in nature, e.g. "armchair psychology." So taken together, "Armchair Apocrypha" sounds like Andrew Bird being typically self-deprecating.

It's another way of calling himself out for the lack of meaning behind the words he's singing, an issue we fucking exhausted last time. But is it actually true on this album? Do the words mean nothing? Is this album so devoid of meaning that I what bitterly wrote about it in 2008 is accurate? Probably not—I was a stupid fuck when I was nineteen years old. But let's find out!

First, though, let's establish once more how neat and fun Andrew Bird's music is. He loops his violin, he whistles, and creates these cool little melodies out of thin air. It's all good. Who needs lyrics, honestly? (And indeed, there are two instrumentals on here, so occasionally, he really doesn't need lyrics.)

But yeah, I mean, there's not much here as far as "I know what Bird is trying to say in this song." I can point to the opener, "Fiery Crash," which is about a fear of flying, and possibly "Dark Matter," a morbid epic that seems to be about the futility of trying to avoid death. Other than that, we have a bunch of great songs that sound amazing but don't warrant a much in the way of lyric annotations.

The big question we need to ask ourselves at this point is: DOES ANY OF THIS MATTER? I.e., the question I seem to be obsessing over (for some fucking reason), whether lyrics actually have meaning... does that matter? At all? Something tells me it's fucking stupid of me to be talking about this ad nauseam, because lyrics can serve different purposes other than, like, imparting a message or telling a story.

Like in the first verse of "Heretics," when each of the five lines ends with "about it" which creates a rhythm in the way the words tumble about and then end the same. There's also a rhythm in the chorus, which goes on for many lines, but basically repeats the same three phrases ("thank god" and "it's fatal" and "not shy") but mixes up their order, keeping the listener off-balance.

Another example is "Scythian Empire," whose subject matter by Bird's own admission was chosen just because it sounded nice against the melody. In it, we have jammed together such phrases as "Halliburton attache cases," "Scotch Guard Mackintoshes shall be carbonized," and "thwarted by the Thracians." None of it makes sense, but man, hearing these SAT words in succession is kind of fucking thrilling in its own way.

The genius annotation for "Armchairs" describes the song as "a good example of the complexity of Bird’s lyrics." The tells me that maybe I'm being too harsh, and that there is value in all of Bird's lyrics, regardless of whether you can tell what the fuck he's talking about. Maybe words in certain combinations can make you feel emotions that you can't express. Maybe Bird's lyrics happen to be filled with those combinations of words, and this is where he finds successful on a deeper level than "this is fun."

My conclusion is that Bird is a poet, and I am not a student of poetry. I think that Bird can (and did) reach a higher level with lyrics that hit harder because they mean something, not just when they "sound good." I don't think Armchair Apocrypha really ever reaches the heights that Andrew Bird is capable of.

Still, all that said, I'm glad this album is in my life, and I'm especially glad that Andrew Bird exists and makes such pleasant music and continues to do so. 2009 Joe was an ignorant asshole. Please ignore what he wrote, and listen to this album.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, try this song: "Plasticities"



~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • The weakest non-instrumental song on the album is probably "Spare-ohs," but that too has some nice wordplay. It took me until this current listen to realize that the title was a homonym of "sparrows," which are also sung about in the song.
  • I may have given a short shrift to the musical elements of this album, a lot of which are a blast. Check out those slinking, persistent drums on "Simple X"!
  • ALBUM COVER: I've always assumed that the front cover's brownish/yellowish shape, laid stark against a black background, was that of a bird, but the backside of the bird. The bird is looking away so you can't see its face. I couldn't find any evidence to the contrary, so let's assume I'm right. I also had a sudden thought... does every Andrew Bird album cover have a picture of a bird?! Because Are You Serious did too! Alas, a quick Wikipedia search showed me that they are the only two with birds, believe it or not.
  • Also something I've never considered: Is "Andrew Bird" his real name?! Wiki seems to indicate yes.
  • I fell in love with Andrew Bird's music the past two weeks, so I'll probably be catching up on a few more of his albums, not that The Albums That Matter has covered all three that I currently own. But don't worry, for alphabetical reasons, you won't have to read about Bird yet again any time soon.

NEXT TIME: Arm's Way by Islands

No comments: