Tuesday, July 17, 2018

Top Five Tuesday: At-Bat Music


We are at the All-Star break, pretty much the halfway point in the MLB season, and I still give a shit about baseball. This feels great! I haven't felt this way since like 2012! The Phillies are currently sitting in first place in the NL East, by the skin of their teeth (0.5 games up). Our team is filled with a bunch of scrubs who somehow have put enough wins together to make a legitimate playoff run. Fuck yeah! I love it!

So yeah, I got baseball on my mind. It's easy to lose yourself in a daydream about playing for the Phillies, isn't it? I have ever since I was a little kid. And the most important thing to me (of course) in this hypothetical alternate universe in which I play baseball professionally is: What my at-bat music would be.

If you're not familiar with the rituals of a baseball game, I'll briefly explain. In the seconds leading up to your turn in the batter's box, i.e. the walk from the on-deck circle to home plate, the music producer for the stadium plays a snippet of music. This music is chosen by the player himself, and so, the music you choose should say something about you as a baseball player or as a person or about your love of the game itself.

Of course, these are professional athletes we are talking about, men who have lived and breathed baseball their entire lives, and ONLY baseball. They didn't have the time growing up to explore the nuances of musical genres. There are no shortstops obsessively reading Stereogum, no left fielders blogging about their yearly Top Tens. And so, the music choices tend to be primitive. Check out this list from 2017 of batters' at-bat music. It's... not pretty.

If I were to make the unlikely jump from overweight social worker to starting second baseman for the Philadelphia Phillies, here are my top five choices for my own at-bat music.

5. The opening guitar riffs of "Queen of Hearts" by Fucked Up


(DJ would start at the beginning)

The raw power of the intro for this song cannot be denied. Sure, the Phillies wouldn't be able to reveal to their family-friendly audience the name of the band who plays the song, and the DJ would have to cut it off before Damian Abraham's cookie monster vocals kick in, but just hearing that guitar riff would get me to launch a few extra home runs for sure.

4. The group chorus from "The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts" by Sufjan Stevens


(DJ would start at the 2:07 mark)

I like the idea that my at-bat music alluding to Superman, because that's what you'd try to be at the plate, lifting your team up with your superhuman strength (and I didn't think "Superman That Ho" would be a good choice for this exercise).

3. The drum fills in "Vincent" by Car Seat Headrest


(DJ would start at the 4:26 mark)

I want to say that this is a selective choice because I feel like the drums are underutilized and underappreciated in typical at-bat music, and I want to support my instrument of choice. But let's be honest, this is just a really cool part in a really cool song and I'd be a cool baseball player by playing it.

2. The refrain from "Four Score and Seven" by Titus Andronicus


(DJ would start at the 7:01 mark)

"It's still us against them!" So goes the refrain at the end of this epic Titus track. Sickles is singing about life in general, but of course, we could easily reappropriate it for baseball. What is baseball if not a battle between Us and Them?

1. The outro of "Powerful Man" by Hop Along


(DJ would start at the 3:01 mark)

A bunch of reasons for this one. One is that it's a great song by a great fucking band. Two is that Hop Along is a local band, and since I'm playing the Phillies in my daydreams, it fits. Three is that great female vocals are absent from most typical at-bat music choices, and so Frances Quinlan could certainly fill that void. I would be fighting against the hypermasculinity of baseball, in other words. Finally, there's a certain irony in using this song. The refrain goes "He looked like a powerful man," which on the surface would fit well with the power I'd be trying to project as a batter. But the lyrics are actually about a guy abusing a child, and the "powerful" part is actually dismissive sarcasm, like, "oh man how POWERFUL you are for punching a child." So the song choice would be self-deprecating. A way to stay humble instead of doing the opposite and projecting steroid-fueled bravado.


Also... BONUS TOP FIVE!

There's another situation in a baseball game where music is integral and chosen by the player. During baseball games in which the starting pitcher underperforms, the manager may choose to call in a relief pitcher. If the relief pitcher is trustworthy enough, then he may even get his own music to run out onto the field to. Think asshole Papelbon running from the bullpen to the hill to the sounds of Metallica's "For Whom the Bell Tolls."

Music is utilized in this case for completely different purposes than at-bat music. A relief pitcher's entrance song not only should say something about the pitcher, but it additionally holds the responsibility of manipulating the crowd in some way. This music should build suspense, or pump the crowd up, or otherwise ask the audience to buy into the drama that is created by having a bullpen pitcher come into a tight spot and attempt to save the day. Plus, more of the actual song is played, maybe up to like two-minute clips of the chosen tune, versus the four seconds you get for an at-bat appearance.

Were I to somehow find myself emerging from the Phillies bullpen with one out in the eighth and two men on, here are the Top Five Songs I'd like the crowd at Citizens Bank Park to get hype on.

5. The chorus of "Lit Up" by the National


(DJ would start at the 1:03 mark)

The irony tickles my fancy. As a relief pitcher, you do NOT want to get lit up. Call it a reverse jinx.

4. The intro for "Time" by Pink Floyd


(DJ would start at the beginning, when the clock alarm stops)

If I were to use this song, I'd be sacrificing the crowd's excitement in the name of ramping up the drama to the nth degree. The great booming bass hits and the creepy tinkling of the keyboard would strike fear in any opposing batter.

3. The bumrush second half of "Incoherent Love Songs" by P.S. Eliot


(DJ would start at the 1:27 mark)

Maybe the message about love and romance would be inappropriate in a baseball game, but you can't deny the excitement that harmonica riff would bring to the masses. And if you don't think about it too hard, "We keep holding on... And it helps to remain valiant" could totally apply to a save situation on the mound.

2. The second half of "Your Graduation" by Modern Baseball


(DJ would start at the 1:06 mark)

I'm ignoring the name of the band because it would be too obvious. We have the DJ start on that snarling, sneering second verse, and continue on to the soaring guitar solo. It also serves as a challenge to the batter to pick their pitch wisely, because as the chorus goes, I will not let them "walk away" to base.

1. Most of "You! Me! Dancing!" by Los Campesinos!


(DJ would start at the beginning, if he can get the timing right)

You ever see baseball players from opposing teams smiling and laughing with each other? Of course. They are friends, at the end of the day. No matter what sports radio tells you, this is all just a game. It's supposed to be fun. I love that about baseball. "You! Me! Dancing!" is a fun as hell song. It gets people up and moving. And it would keep the fun in the game. It's you (the batter)! It's me (the pitcher)! We're dancing! The crowd could dance around too. Baseball is fucking fun! If I am going to be a relief pitcher, I want to remember that!

No comments: