Wednesday, July 11, 2018

Restaurant Review: Hungry Pigeon

Puke on Your Birthday reviews entertainment every Wednesday, taking a break from the usual inane nonsense and inconsequential bullshit typically posted here. This week, we reflect on a dinner at a top-tier Philly restaurant, Hungry Pigeon.


Hungry Pigeon
Queen Village, Philadelphia
Open seven days a week
Make a reservation online

I love life every goddamn second I'm with the baby, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't want to step away occasionally. To enjoy a night with Pam as "wife" and not "baby momma." And plus, my parents have been consistently bothering me for months at this point about when the fuck they can babysit please. So we got out of the house last Friday, put on some decent, unstained-by-formula clothes, and went on a date night.

Hungry Pigeon was the perfect place for such a night, as it turns out.

First, we got pretty lit up at Southwark down the street, but this isn't a review of Southwark so I won't say too much more about it (and also because the happy hour featured a clumsy, tipsy Joe spill discount red wine all over Pam's dress, so I guess the less we harp on this experience the better).

Let's point out here that Hungry Pigeon is sitting pretty as the #1 rated restaurant in the city right now by Philadelphia Magazine. Typically, this would be a deterrent for yours truly. I have a feeling that the #1 slot is usually reserved for snooty, overpriced chophouses and the like. The type of restaurant where I'd feel out-of-place in. Not so with Hungry Pigeon, I was assured. The atmosphere was comfortable and boisterous, I was told.

And it's all true. That atmosphere was pretty great. We had a seat right by the large window up front, and so we got a lot of natural light, even as the summer sun disappeared. It was a little loud in there, but then, so were we I'm sure (happy hour does that to new, alcohol-deprived parents). It felt more like a family atmosphere than a noisy nuisance. Family meals are supposed to be loud, aren't they? It's more fun that way. Please don't take me to a restaurant where I feel like I have to whisper.

Is it time to gush about the food yet? Because I'm ready.

We chose the option on the menu where you just let the cooks make some shit for you. They even choose your drinks to accompany each course. Honestly, I wish every good restaurant had this option. There's always the possibility that you are getting fucked, pricewise, like maybe the cooks are specifically making sure that what they are giving is worth less than what you are paying. That's my frugal paranoia speaking, and it has no place in a joint like Hungry Pigeon. Clearly, the food is prepared with the customer in mind, not their wallets. I have no problem with trusting these folks to just do what they love to do.

The first course was three different appetizers (served with a fruity rhubarb whiskey type drink? It was the perfect summer cocktail). We had your cucumber and zucchini salad with toasted nuts (I think? Jesus, I'm terrible at knowing what to call fancy food). We had your roasted root vegetables with a jalapeño chipotle sauce to complement. And then we had your seared scallions on top of a fresh corn salsa. No sure which was better, but there were no flaws to find in any dish. The waitress gave us one of those "wow you sure WERE hungry based on how clean the plates are aha aha" looks when she came to collect the dishes.

I think the rhubarb whisky might've put Pam over the edge, because she was adorable at this point. Conversation ranged from laughing about her ex-boyfriend still takes pictures of his meals for Instagram, to tearing up when we discuss whether there is an actual afterlife. The waitress questioned at this point why Pam's eyes were bloodshot, so I explained that it was our first night away from the baby, and we were getting a little wild. She understood.

Second course was this pasta thing. And honestly, this review is about to go off the rails, because asking the waiter to repeat what exactly the food is made of is rude as fuck and we didn't do it, we just shoved that tasty shit down our gullets. And it was fucking fantastic. I think it had gnocchi cheese in it, but don't quote me on that. We also got a beer to wash it down. It was a good beer, let's say a light, airy IPA of some sort. We drank them out of mason jars because it's 2018 and we are still looking to Pinterest for inspiration.

I was pretty drunk too at this point and I gotta say Pam looked A+ in her summer dress and I did my usual thing where I try to persuade her to accompany me to the unisex bathroom and she did her usual thing and rolled her eyes but still smirked because she secretly likes when I proposition her with public bathroom sex.

ANYWAY, the main entrée was a swordfish and a vegetable that I don't remember. Fucking bangin'. It was so fresh, and so impeccably cooked, it fell apart without the assistance of a knife, and melted in your mouth. I could've gone for a little more seasoning on the thing, if we're being petty about it, but I think that speaks more toward my deficiencies as a cook (Overseasoned Salmon Night every Tuesday at the K*** household) than toward any fault of the Pigeon chefs. There's no denying that it was tasty, seasoning or no. And I honestly had to put something negative in the post, right? What's a food critic without impossibly high standards?

The dessert course consisted of a thicc piece of carrot cake, with a scoop raspberry sorbet and a scoop of moosetrack fudge ice cream on the side. The drink for this course was limoncello, which was warm and pretty sweet (too sweet?), but it went pretty good with the succulent cake.

And the cake even had a candle burning on it when it came out, since the waitress wanted to celebrate with us our first night out without the anxieties of a baby. It rounded out a night of fucking excellent service. We were tucked in a corner all night, but it never felt like the waitress forgot about us at any point. It felt like she gave a shit, I guess? Which I know is a low bar to clear, but as a former awful waiter myself, a lot of people can't even clear that bar at all.

Now, the question you've all been waiting for: Was it expensive? The answer to that is yes. This is a "special occasion" restaurant, through and through, for us working class folk. But I can honestly say it wasn't prohibitively expensive. We were comfortable with the price. And yo, it was sooo fucking worth it. Great food, great experience (and great company, it's worth noting again).

I guess you can take this review with a grain of salt if you want. I mean, we were a little drunk and it was the first night out without the baby, which was a relief despite the fact that we missed her. And even though me and Pam rarely go out to dinner anywhere above the level of "Decent Bar Food," I have been to enough of these highfalutin, Philly Mag-recommend, Laban-endorsed, so-called Top Tier Philadelphia Restaurants to know when one is worth the hype. Hungry Pigeon is worth the hype, trust me.

GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5

No comments: