There are plenty of places to get a good cheesesteak in Philadelphia, but I would argue there are only a handful of famous cheesesteak shops. After visiting John’s this morning for an early lunch (or late breakfast?), I am confident I’ve been to all the "famous" spots in Philly, and can be counted on as a source of Philly cheesesteak knowledge.
You want cheesesteak opinions? Haha yeah man, I got cheesesteak opinions.
The first and most asked question is, obviously: What is the best cheesesteak in the city? And it’s a great question! It’s one that I’ll never get tired of arguing with people over.
Honestly, my top cheesesteak right now is Joe’s in Fishtown. Joe’s gets everything right. There’s ample chopped meat, the cheese is melted to the right consistency, the roll is fresh. It’s a hearty sandwich, and it fucking hits the spot every time.
I hesitate to call John’s the best cheesesteak in the city, even though when I was eating that shit this morning, I was certainly entertaining the idea. I hesitate only because I am afraid that it might be recency bias. I might need a few more cracks at it. But for real, the cheesesteak today kind of blew me away. What put it over the top, besides the flavorful meat and melty cheese, was the seeded rolls. No other reputable cheesesteak place does seeded rolls, and they really made a difference in a good way.
Until the past few years, Jim’s had been my favorite cheesesteak. As I alluded to in my quiche post, Jim’s holds a special place in my heart as my first real cheesesteak. Tasting Jim’s brings back so many great memories, from drunken freshman year outings, to post-strip-club sojourns at the Northeast location, to bizarrely bringing at least TWO high school dates there, like, why? But Jim’s was where it’s at.
If we’re being truthful, though, and putting nostalgia aside, Jim’s steaks are great but not top tier. Sometimes there isn’t enough meat. Occasionally you get the chewy meat. Rarely is the American Cheese melted enough, or even at all. Not every bite of Jim’s is great. Some bites cause me to see stars. Others leave me wanting.
If you’re a Northeast Philly Bro, you probably sing the praises of Steve’s Prince of Steaks. I don’t get the hype. As with every cheesesteak on this list, Steve’s steaks are at least very good, but I disagree with anyone that claims they are great.
First issue—the meat is sliced, not chopped, which is definitely not my preference. I feel like the meat loses some flavor when there’s less surface area hitting that grille. And you also get that phenomenon in which you take a bite of your sandwich, and your teeth end up accidentally pulling out half the meat from the bread. I don’t want to spend any time reconstructing cheesesteaks, ya know?
My second issue is the cheese. My go-to cheese is American, and Steve’s uses American cheese from a hot vat instead of melting slices of it. By the time your sandwich hits your mouth, the cheese is already coagulating in a weird way, a way that almost gives it a chalky texture.
At this point, let me again stress that even the worst of the cheesesteaks on this list are tasty and I would gladly eat any one of them at the drop of a hat. But if we’re comparing, it’s worth nitpicking, and of all the sandwiches on this list, I have the most complaints about Steve’s, however insignificant. But when you saw me at age 22, drunk on the Boulevard, eating a Steve’s steak (while trying to hide from the employees after an even drunker friend punched out a screen window in the eating area), you didn’t hear me complaining, believe you me.
Let’s take a break from talking about cheesesteak tastes, not only because I’m running out of adjectives that could describe meat and cheese, but also because there’s another important aspect of any cheesesteak shop, the atmosphere. The experience is almost as important as the sandwich itself.
That’s why I hate when I read online when Philly natives try to dissuade tourists from going to Pat’s and Geno’s. Yes, both sandwiches are extremely disappointing to anyone with standards, but going to the corner of 9th and Passyunk is a MUST for anyone that hasn’t done so already. It’s a cultural experience. Waiting in line, practicing how to order properly (don’t say the word "cheese" and don’t say the word "steak"!), enjoying your sandwich under the neon lights on a summer night, probably drunk, probably after the bars close. No matter how shitty Pat’s and Geno’s sandwiches are, I always find myself sitting on a bright orange table under the awning at least once a year anyway, enjoying every bite.
But make no mistake, both sandwiches are not very good compared to the other Philadelphia titans. The bottom line is that they are made too quickly, the sandwich-building almost assembly-line in nature. If you order your American Wit’out at 9:00 PM, you have your sandwich by 9:03 PM. To me that says the cheesesteak wasn’t made with love and care. It was thrown together. And it usually shows. Sometimes there’s so little meat it might as well be a bread sandwich.
If some South Philly lowlife put a gun to my head and told me to choose between the two, I’d definitely pick Pat’s over Geno’s. For better or worse, I still hold a grudge against Geno’s for what I (and many others) perceived to be a racist sign in their window for many years, the infamous "This is America, when ordering, SPEAK ENGLISH."
Like with the Broad Street median parking and the Frank Rizzo statue, people from South Philly by and large have nearsighted and uneducated opinions about nearly anything you could possibly ask them about. Refusing business to people who don’t speak English is preposterous, but the sign stood for over a decade, because 9th and Passyunk is MURICA! Fuck Geno’s.
In writing this blog post, however, I did find this article, which indicates that the sign (probably?) has been taken down for good. Geno Vento, the now-owner (and son of Joey Vento, the original owner and apparent racist until his very last breath), appears to be a lot less of a blowhard than his dad (which make him way less South Philly-ish, right?). Maybe Geno’s is trying to turn over a new leaf in these polarizing political times.
Which, if they are, maybe it’s time to lift the grudge. If I can afford to extend the courtesy to Joe’s (of which I’m an unabashed fanboy, despite the fact that until a few years ago the franchise was known by the racially insensitive name "Chink’s"), I guess I can try to extend my forgiveness to Geno’s as well.
Doesn’t mean they have a great cheesesteak, though.
Hey, you know what’s annoying? People that think Dalessandro’s has the best cheesesteak in the city.
I’m just kidding, Dalessandro’s definitely has a good sandwich. Chopped meat, just how I like it. Cheese is a nice consistency. Rolls are soft. I’ve gotten Dalessandro’s while drunk and it was truly a delight.
But if I’ve shit on Northeast Philly and South Philly, I guess I have to shit on Northwest Philly as well. I feel like a lot of people in 17th grade who live in Manayunk like to claim Dalessandro’s as the best just because it’s in their neck of the woods, and people who live in Manayunk are afraid to leave their bubble. Yeah brah, Dalessandro’s really hits the spot after a long night of hitting on busty drunk girls at Mad River!!
Plus, Chubby’s is right across the street, which has a sandwich that is right up there in terms of quality, but also has a bar inside, which makes it perplexing to me why people would wait in that Dalessandro’s line.
Tony Luke’s is the final of the Big Eight that we haven’t discussed yet, and I did not save the best for last. I probably had my first Tony Luke’s two years ago, and I was not impressed. The best way I can describe the sandwich is... mushy? Like, it was too soft to bite. The bread seemed wet with grease, and not in a good way. the meat lacked flavor.
I’ve heard rumors that Tony Luke’s has gone downhill since they aggressively expanded their brand. When you’re selling sandwiches at the baseball stadium, the airport, the fucking Deptford Mall, you can’t really guarantee quality. Compare it to John’s, which has one single location, and every sandwich is made with great love by a group of sweaty, easily-upset jamooks huddling over a grill with painstaking care. Tony Luke’s suffers in ubiquity.
I’ve almost written 1500 words about Philadelphia cheesesteaks already, and we’ve only talked about the Big Eight! There are a thousand other places to get a decent and "authentic" steak in Philly. Past the most famous ones, we have second-tier famous steak places like Campo’s, Sonny’s, and Shank’s. You have places like the Malt House in Port Richmond that are putting a twist on the formula (kielbasa meat instead of steak). You have dive bars like Oscar’s putting out worthy competitors (and you get a cheesesteak-and-a-half for the price of one during happy hour!). You might even have a strip club putting together a worthy cheesesteak, for free!
My doctor told me yesterday that I really need to change my diet, but I’ll be honest, I’m always gonna make an exception for a good cheesesteak.
FINAL RANKINGS OF THE BIG EIGHT:
8. Tony Luke’s
7. Geno’s
6. Steve’s
5. Pat’s
4. Dalessandro’s
3. Jim’s
2. John’s
1. Joe’s
Love,
Joey

No comments:
Post a Comment